What is the difference between an Archduchy and a Grand Duchy?

Question

What is the difference between an Archduchy and a Grand Duchy?

Is an Archduchy the same thing as a Grand Duchy, different in name only? Were there ever any Archduchies besides the Archduchy of Lorraine/Lotharingia and the Archduchy of Austria?

Answer 1

A Grand Duchy is a territory who's head of state is a Grand Duke or Grand Duchess.There is only one Grand Duchy and that is Luxembourg(according to Wikipedia).

An Archduchy is headed by an Archduke or Archduchess.Archdukes/duchesses are HIGHER in rank than a Grand Duke/Duchess.

According to Wikipedia archduchies include  House of Habsburg and the House of Habsburg-Lorraine.

Here is what Wikipedia says: "The English word is recorded only since 1530, derived from Middle - via Old French archeduc, from Merovingian Latin archidux, from arch(i)- (see arch- (adj.)) + dux 'duke' .

Archduke (Erzherzog) is a title distinct from Grand Duke (Großherzog or Großfürst), used in some other German royal houses and still in sovereign Luxemburg.

First use was as a the title of the rulers of Austrasia (c.750), one of the Frankish realms resulting from the complex successions in the house of Clovis, roughly comprising Germany, Switzerland and the Low Countries.

In the Carolingian Empire it was awarded as a unique promotion to the duke of Lotharingia (much larger then Lorraine), which could be seen as successor to the former Carolingian kingdom of Lothringia which had been at par at least with West Francia (modern France) in the dynastic divisions under the early heirs of Charlemagne but ended up absorbed by East Francia (Greater Germany).

After the split (959) of the (arch)duchy into Upper- (German Oberlothringen, including modern Lorraine) and Lower Lothringia (German Niederlothringen, north of it, with seat at Cologne and originally vested in its prince-archbishop, but extending north all the way to Frisia) and the latter's further fragmentation, two of the 'succeeding' duchies in the Low Countries, Brabant (mainly in present Belgium) and Gelre (now in the Dutch kingdom and giving its name to the province of Gelderland), claimed the archducal rank but were never officially granted it by the Holy Roman Emperor. The Dutch form is Aartshertog.



Crown of the Archduke of Austria.The title Archduke of Austria, the only one to become generally notable, was invented in the Privilegium Maius, a 14th century forgery initiated by Duke Rudolf IV of Austria. Originally, it was meant to denote the ruler of the (thus 'Arch')duchy of Austria, in an effort to put that ruler on par with the Prince-electors, as Austria had been passed over in the Golden Bull of 1356, when the electorships had been assigned. Holy Roman Emperor Charles IV refused to recognize the title.

Duke Ernest the Iron and his descendants unilaterally assumed the title "archduke";

This title was only officially recognized in 1453 by Emperor Frederick III, when the Habsburgs had (permanently) gained control of the office of the Holy Roman Emperor.

First it was granted to Frederick's younger brother, Albert VI of Austria (d. 1463), who used the title at least from 1458.

In 1477, Frederick III granted the title archduke also to his first cousin, Sigismund of Austria, ruler of Further Austria.

Frederick's son and heir, the future Emperor Maximilian I, started to use the title, but obviously only after the death of his wife Mary of Burgundy (d. 1482) as the title never appears in documents of joint Maximilian and Mary rule in the Low Countries (where Maximilian is still titled Duke of Austria). The title appears first in documents of joint Maximilian and Philip (his under-age son) rule in the Low Countries.

Emperor Frederick III himself used just Duke of Austria, never Archduke, until his death in 1490.

Ladislaus the Posthumous, Duke of Austria, who died in 1457, was never in his lifetime authorized to use it, and accordingly, not he nor anyone in his branch of the dynasty ever used the title.

Female children of the dynasty were not yet entitled to the title in the 15th century. It was used only by those dynasts who ruled a Habsburg territory, i.e., only by males and their consorts.

[edit] Other dynastic Habsburg use

Often imprecisely rendered as Grand Duke (actually a lower rank with which it should not be confused), Grand Prince (in German Großfürst, not Großherzog) was used for the rulers of Lithuania (which in 1386 formed a personal union with Poland) and Moscovia, the nucleus of later imperial Russia until its ruler assumed the sovereign style Tsar of royal rank, and still later emperor in imperial Russia. "Archduke" was used for non-sovereign rulers as a titular rank for princes of the Austrian ruling house of Habsburg, in titulary chief of an Austrian homeland but without becoming its hereditary ruler since all territories remained vested in the Austrian crown. Occasionally it might be combined with a separate gubernatorial mandate.

From the 16th century onward, Archduke and its female form, Archduchess, came to be used by all the members of the House of Habsburg, similar to the title Prince (of the blood) in many other royal houses. For example, Queen Marie Antoinette of France was born Maria Antonia, Archduchess of Austria. This practice was maintained, after the dissolution of the Holy Roman Empire, in the Austrian Empire (1804-1867) and the Austro-Hungarian Empire (1867-1918).

With the abolition of the imperial monarchy in 1919, noble titles and the peerage system were abolished in Austria. Thus, those members of the extended Habsburg family who are citizens of the federal Republic of Austria, are simply known by their respective first name and their surname, Habsburg-Lothringen. The use of aristocratic titles such as archduke is in fact illegal in Austria. However, some members of the family who are citizens of other countries such as Germany, where aristocratic titles have become part of the name, may use the title."

Answer 2

Arduchy  (arch meaning "chief")

the domain controlled by an archduke or archduchess.

Archduke denotes a rank above Duke and under King. It has only ever been continuously borne by princes of the House of Habsburg and later through the female line into the House of Habsburg-Lorraine. "Archduke" was used for non-sovereign rulers as a titular rank for princes of the Austrian ruling house of Habsburg, in titulary chief of an Austrian homeland but without becoming its hereditary ruler since all territories remained vested in the Austrian crown.

http://wapedia.mobi/en/Archduchy (interesting link)

Grand Duchy

Grand duke is the usual and established translation of grand prince in languages which do not have separate words meaning prince for (1) children of a monarch, and (2) monarch (sovereign or like) princes. English and French use Grand Duke also in this way.

1. Western Grand Dukes

2. Grand Prince

3. Byzantine Grand Dukes

4. Russian Grand Dukes

http://wapedia.mobi/en/Grand_Duke (interesting link)