What is the ideal composition for the Indian team?

Question

What do you fans think? It is always good to get an outside perspective. Should the Indian team rely more on youth or experience? As it may be apparent, the one day team is very much a new look team, with some seniors missing out lately. What do the fans feel about this?

Also would you say that fielding is the most important out of the the three departments of batting, bowling, and fielding? We are currently focussing very much on the fielding aspect. The batting and bowling, every team has and every player is expected to perform....but it could be the fielding which sets one team apart from another.

Answer 1

I believe  India has a surfiet of talent to choose from, in all departments of the game. Sorry for seeming nasty !

Answer 2

select 20twenty squad for ODi matches too...Lol~

Answer 3

i think that your a Liar and a poser for coming on here pretending to be MS Dhoni, we all know better than that, also i think you should GET OUT!

EDIT: i see where your coming from Binga, but having checked out Dhonis profile you will see that this person is genuinely pretending to be MS Dhoni, whereas everyone can see you are not brett lee, if you were youd also have an "official" badge, also you dont pretend to be him unlike this person is doing

Answer 4

YOUTH S IMPORTANT THAN EXPERIENCE ACCORDING TO MY POINTOF VIEW.BUT AS U SAID THE ODI TEAM HAS CHANGED COMPLETELY.BUT NO PROBLEM.IF WE WIN A MATCH THAT'S GOOD.

ACCORDING TO ME ALL ARE IMPORTANT.BUT INDIA SHOULD IMPROVE IN FIELDING,BOWLING TOO.BUT DHONI IS NOT PLAYING AS BEFORE. I AM WAITING TO SEE HIM PLAYING  LIKE BEFORE........

Answer 5

Yes, it's good to go with the younger players. Australia has had to cope with losing some great players in the last two seasons, Warne, Langer,Martin,McGrath,Gilchrist & now McGill. But we put faith in the replacements who, by & large are keeping up their end.I think India would do well to give the younger players a go.

Edit. Ashish B/OZ, have you got a permanent burr under your saddle blanket, or were you born nasty. All your insults mean nothing to us, it's old news, so you should try to get over it like other Indians here have.The asker has posed a very fair question.

Edit 2. Marco, I am taking the Dhoni ID with a grain of salt, as I would have expected anyone else to.Do I not call myself Bingalee?

Answer 6

keeping things simple like ms dhoni

1) gambhir

2) sehwag

3) tendulkar/uthappa

4) yuvraj

5) rohit sharma/raina/manoj tiwary

6) ms dhoni

7) irfan pathan/praveen kumar

8) piyush chawla

9) sreesanth

10) ishant sharma

11) rp singh/ramesh powar

they others can be made the 12th 13th and so on members of the team