What is your opinion on the twilight petition?

Question

have you signed it

i havent and i wont but i am devastated that she decided no to do it but i think it is unfair for fans to try and make her write a book that she doesnt feel should be written now i think thats its her choice and that we should let her make the choice

Answer 1

i havent signed it

i think tht us fans shouldnt be begging her to write it. she doesn't deserve that.

Answer 2

I went to the link above (posted by Samantha) and read the petition.

Why doesn't someone correct the darn thing?  Twilight fans should be embarrassed to sign it the way it's written -- unless they are perfectly happy to appear illiterate and thus confirm the general opinion that they are.

This is the last line of the petition statement:

"The leak shouldn't be the cause of this book getting unfinished."

How does a book -- or anything -- get unfinished?  When it comes to being unfinished, something either is or it isn't.  It can't 'get' that way.

Look, I know most Twilighters are young teens and, for that reason, I have never once posted a critism here.   But jeeze, people...

Answer 3

I TOTALLY agree with you. Okay, yeah. Writing a 400 page book takes up a really long time. Stephenie has the right not to write a book when she doesn't want to !! How about writing a petition on some more important things than forcing an author to write a book?

Answer 4

Oh, the "BD was not such an epic failure, we love whatever what you write being high on whatever that you do, just please write and give us our bible, we will buy anything and we will adore you from now on!!" thingy?

Should I?

Answer 5

I do agree with you, but instead of signing a petition for her to continue writing the book, we should all her just show her that we support her in some way

Answer 6

yes i have signed it and think any twilight fan should.

and many people agree we have over 3400 people who have signed already

Save Midnight Sun

http://www.ipetitions.com/petition/savem...

Answer 7

My opinion is that she should have been Careful with the manuscript, and that the Midnight Sun Fiasco is not the greatest Tragedy to have struck the world at the moment.

TW K

Answer 8

I agree with you.

If you like stephanie meyer, and not just her books you would let her make her own decision, it would be hard for her to continue that she was disrespected by her fans. I will NOT sign a petition, but I am a true stephanie meyer fan. I respect her own decision, and rights as a human.