What pitcher(s) do you think I can get for Justin Verlander, Pedro Martinez and Andy Pettitte?

Question

I've already offered all three for Cole Hamels, Scott Kazmir, and Roy Halladay. All three offers were rejected. Who should I target next that would have a realistic chance of being accepted?

Answer 1

Well Hamels is pitching better then Verlander, Kazmir is much better then Pedro now, and Halladay is better then Pettite. You could maybe get a star pitcher and 2 mediocre pitchers. But that's what you're trading away. I would just hold on to all 3 pitchers.

Answer 2

I wouldn't trade any of these three guys for just one pitcher.

I know there all mediocre right now, but I see upside in all of them as the year progresses.

If your really looking for a solid guy though, you may want to try Ben Sheets, Webb, or package 2 in a Eric Bedard deal.