What player "Made in Mexico" has the better résumé? Rafa Marquez or Mauro Camoranesi?

Question

Who knew that 17 yr old that took Atlas one penalty away from winning its first championship in 50 yrs would soon move to Barcelona and win the Champions League and several Spanish Titles.

Who knew that the same person that started his career in Torreon Mexico would win Santos first championship then move on to play in Cruz Azul where he was the best midfielder in all of Mexico those 2 years and would take him to the Italian National team and Juventus where he has won several titles and a World Cup

Answer 1

Mauro Camoranesi

Answer 2

Rafa Marquez because Camoranesi is not mexican.

Camoranesi was born in Tandil,Argentina.

Answer 3

hmm, that's tough. we're talking WC v CL, here. WCs are less often but there is more competition in the CL. both offer the same amount of talent. both seem improbable to win for any team. both players were instrumental in their team's glory. most football analysts would give the nod to a WC over a CL. i'm not discarding the La Liga titles that Rafa helped contribute to, or the Serie A titles that Mauro won with Juve.... but i guess it would depend on you, if you think the CL or WC is more impressive

@italian stallion:

wow. your stupidity scares me for humanity.

the asker never denied he was italian, he just said that his real career started in mexico.

Answer 4

When you talk about who has the BETTER RESUME??  Without a doubt that its Camaranesi and he has a world cup to back it up!  

Answer 5

I think based on accomplishments within the Mexican League, one would say Mauro Camoranesi. He started out in Mexico, went to Chile/Argentina but it wasn't till he played for Cruz Azul where he made a name for himself and appeared to be one of the best players in the country during his time there.

Rafa Marquez moved to Monaco at an early age, so I don't think Atlas truly got the best years out of him (very typical for clubs in Latin America to lose their young talented players to European teams)

Answer 6

camoranessi cuz he played for the best team santos

Answer 7

Marquez

Answer 8

Rafa Marquez no doubt

Answer 9

camoranesi played only like 3 years in mexico

Answer 10

camoranesi, world cup victory

Answer 11

Camoranesi