What spices should I use for this pie fillling?

Question

I have some crab apple sauce which is pretty stout. I like to make pie by substituting apple sauce for pumpkin pie filling and making a pie like a pumpkin pie. I use the spices for the pumpkin pie recipe and it is really good but are there some other spices I could use instead?

Answer 1

cinnamon SUGAR, nutmeg?

Answer 2

Your apple sauce pie inspires an idea - how about a pork chop apple pie?

As someone mentioned, for good apple flavor, I would use real apples. My favorite for baking is granny smith, as they are really tart (sweeten when cooked) and hold up their shape well.

http://www.recipesecrets.net/forums/reci...

Answer 3

You can't make a pumpkin pie with no pumpkin.  Applesauce alone would make a nasty pie in my opinion.  Why not use fresh apples?

Answer 4

I think your pumpkin-crab apple pie sounds great!  I also enjoy a pumpkin or butternut squash pie made w/ apple butter, so I would think your crabapple sauce would be an excellent addition.

Answer 5

How about some herbs instead I was thinking Nightshade and Hemlock.......but not to much. : )

Answer 6

Cinnamon  and nutmeg.