What would affect you more? Your Sun sign or other signs all the same sign?

Question

Say your sun sign is umm Taurus and your moon is also Taurus and so is your rising, but the rest were all air signs, nothing else, would you be more of a Taurus or the air signs?

Ok, let's say, you're sign sun is an air sign and so is your rising and moon but different air signs, the rest of your chart is flooded with water signs, what would you be more?

Or if you had a fire sun sign, a water moon sign, an air rising and the rest were earth signs? Would you be more earthy?

Answer 1

Hey. You're avatar is identical to mine! Except mine is sad right now.

Oh and to answer your question....I'm not so sure. I think all of the planets in the placements in your natal chart shape who you are. But you definitely would act more like a Taurus if you had your Sun, moon, and rising in that placment!

Answer 2

This is an interesting question Danger, but I would think that with the same elements in the Sun, Moon, and Rising, that would outweigh any of the others. You'd still have those secondary influences, but those are basically the most important when considering your needs and wants and ways of dealing with others. Having your Sun, Moon, and Rising in the same sign is very rare, but it is possible. So I would say that the if you had all of those in Taurus, you would be very earthy, as the other planets are too light weight to overpower a combination like that. However, having your Sun, Moon, and Rising in a certain elemental house, and strong aspects between the other planets might give more strength to the other element....So I guess this is a question for an experienced astrologer to answer.

Edit: The only reason nobody is answering is because of the time. Most of the time, the people that really know about this stuff are on during the day, so that's when you'll get a question like this answered. You just have to wait until more people come on to Yahoo. You'll get more answers, I'm sure.

By me, it's 12:30 am. Lol.