What would be the starting lineup and rotation for the AL EAST and NL EAST allstar teams if they face play?

Question

Here's mine.....

AL EAST ROTATION

1. Roy Halladay

2. Josh Beckett

3. Chein Ming Wang

4. AJ Burnett

5. Scott Kazmir

Lineup

1. Carl Crowford

2. Derek Jeter

3. David Ortiz

4. Alex Rodriguez

5. Jason Bay

6. Carlos Pena

7. JD Drew

8. Mike Lowell

9. Alex Rios

Answer 1

NL Rotation

1. Johan Santana

2. Cole Hamels

3. Tim Hudson (he is on DL but so is Wang)

4. Oliver Perez (great big game pitcher)

5. Ricky Nolasco/ Josh Johnson

Lineup

1. Jose Reyes

2. Carlos Beltran

3. Chipper Jones

4. Ryan Howard

5. Chase Utley

6. David Wright DH

7. Brian Mcann

8. Pat Burell

9. Daniel Murphey

You have to remember the braves and Nationals have traded all of their quality players and the NL east has a lot of strong infielders. Jose/Hanley/J Roll

Answer 2

Are you basing your lineup from the best? Becuase some of these players play the same position.

AL Rotation.

1.Roy Halladay

2.Mike Mussina

3.James Shields

4.Joba Chamberlain

5.Josh Beckett

Lineup-

1.Dustin Pedroia

2.Derek Jeter

3.Ortiz

4.A-rod

5.Carolos Pena

6.Jorge Posada

7.JD Drew

8.Xavier Nady

9.Vernon Wells

NL Rotation

1.John Smoltz

2.Johan Santana

3.Cole Hammels

4.Tim Hudson

5.Jamie Moyer/Oliver Perez

Lineup

1.Jose Reyes

2.Jimmy Rollins(DH)

3.Chase Utley

4.Ryan Howard

5.Chipper Jones

6.Pat Burrell

7.Carlos Beltran

8.Brian McCann

9.RF is weak in this division so i would put a centerfielder over there and put Shane Victorino.

Answer 3

I love questions like these - they give me a reason to make a blind spreadsheet!  LOL  ... if anyone wants to debate these picks, I'm more than happy to give my reasons.

AL EAST

Starting Rotation

1. Roy Halladay, TOR

2. Jeremy Guthrie, BAL

3. Jon Lester, BOS

4. Daisuke Matsuzaka, BOS

5. Shawn Marcum, TOR

Lineup

1. 2B Brian Roberts, BAL

2. OF J.D. Drew, BOS

3. 3B Alex Rodriguez, NYY

4. DH Aubrey Huff, BAL

5. 1B Kevin Youkilis, BOS

6. OF Nick Markakis, BAL

7. OF Bobby Abreu, NYY

8. SS Derek Jeter, NYY

9. C Dioner Navarro, TBR

NL EAST

Starting Rotation

1. Johan Santana, NYM

2. Cole Hamels, PHI

3. Tim Hudson, ATL**

4. Jair Jurrjens, ATL

5. Ricky Nolasco, FLA

(** As Hudson is injured, Jamie Moyer - PHI, would fill in for him)

Lineup

1. SS Hanley Ramirez, FLA

2. 3B David Wright, NYM

3. OF Pat Burrell, PHI

4. 2B Chase Utley, PHI

5. 1B Carlos Delgado, NYM

6. C Brian McCann, ATL

7. OF Carlos Beltran, NYM

8. OF Shane Victorino, PHI