What would happen if undocumented taxpayers start an armed Revolution to get their Civil Rights?

Question

?

Answer 1

The CIA won't let that happen! Fear factor ,

prozac nations can't start revolutions!

Answer 2

Sounds like a contradiction in terms "undocumented taxpayer."

Answer 3

There would have to be a new party for it to suceed and a clear form of economic organization to make sure it was not a repeat of what had gone before. There would be a change in that more than one party would be in The U.S.A.  The Revolutionary Party could be  a Socialist Party with the idea of stopping Global Warming and helping Society as well as to gain their rights. To have help from Mexico and other nations would help as well. This should not be necessary and other Anericans should see benefit in a new political structure without violence. Apply more pressure .

Answer 4

Do you read a lot of fiction?. indocumented taxpayers from Canada or Europe?

Answer 5

They would probably lose if they  were armed.  The United States doesn't exactly like their undocumented taxpayers.

Answer 6

it might happen!

Answer 7

In other words? Illegal Aliens?

Massive Crackdown, and immediate shipping OUT of the country comes most readily to  mind.

If you're here illegally, you've chosen to disobey the laws.  What right do you have to demand that the laws be altered to favor you?

Answer 8

undocumented taxpayers? How would any taxpayer be undocumented? They have to have identification #'s to file taxes!

Answer 9

The  upper class or wealthy folks will become poor,  and the poor class will take over, like in any other revolution...

Answer 10

First and foremost, there is NO such thing as an undocumented  taxpayer.   You must be documented in order to pay state and federal taxes.  Now that said, if you mean the undocumented Illegal aliens that have robbed this country of the benifits that true citizens and taxpayers are supposed to be entitled to then that is a horse of a different color!

  These Illegal aliens may pay some taxes ie: groceries, gasoline, clothing and so on. But nobody is taking 30%-40% of their yearly wages in order to fund the programs that THEY rely upon for their healthcare and their families healthcare. Nor for the Food, Clothing and Housing programs they are so willing to patronize.

Most live in homes where one person is Documented or has obtained Legal Citizenship.  They crowd anywhere from 3 to 10 or more families in to Single Family dwellings( don't tell me they don't, we have 2 such homes on our street and I have been to homes for sale that look like RABBIT WARRENS) blankets sectioning off spaces in basements, mini fridges, microwaves and hotplates in each "SPACE". Yes they all help the home owner pay his mortgage and he must pay property taxes.  But think about this, one single dwelling family home( I'll be nice) five families living in it.  Now each of these five families have school age children. Lets say they each have 2 children each that got to the local schools which that home is being property taxed on.  Now the taxes are only for ONE family living in ONE home not for a multitude! So that's 10 children going to school for the price of 2!  It's simple math.  Schools are overcrowded, they are burdoned by the need for extra money for new schools, more teachers, and special programs to teach these students english.

As to what would happen if these persons started a revolution for their Cival rights.  There can be no Cival rights in a country for persons that are not accounted for. And if they choose to arm themselves and try and take this action by force then they should be dealt with as any other TERRORIST would be..imprisoned and or shot on site!

Answer 11

they pay tax wen they shop

and they pay tax wen they have Illegal documents like they assume the Identity of a dead relative or Friends that were born in this country and die in Mexico= or they know some one that for 600 the will give them papers and a social security number

and they go apply for well fare and the hole works and no one checks to see if is legal or not and you you think that they want a revolution?????????? there is no other country to rip off

Answer 12

Depends on the scope.

If the armed revolution was small enough, local law enforcement agencies would respond to deal with it.

If larger, it might require state governors to activate National Guard units.

Answer 13

What the h**l are "undocumented taxpayers," and what "civil rights" do they have?  If you're talking about illegal immigrants, most don't pay taxes (they don't have a social security number), and only "citizens" have rights that are protected under the Constitution.

Answer 14

If you happen to be referring to illegal aliens, such as the Mexicans that have been invading America, the reprisal would be stunning. Anybody that looked like they were Mexican, citizen or not would probably be shot first, and questions asked later, if at all. It would a very bloody time for all and every far right wing hate group would feel just cause to enter into the fray. The police would be over whelmed and martial law would probably be issued. Additionally, I would not be at all surprised to find civilian militia groups invading northern Mexico to carry the "war" to that area.

As for their "civil rights", they have none because they are NOT citizens of the United States. ALL of them should be banned from getting any kind of aid here and now. No schools, no medical help, no food stamps, nothing, no support of any kind. If a Mexican person shows up seeking aid, they had best have a valid green card in hand, or a birth certificate showing that they are a natural born US citizen. To add to this, we should make it a rule, anyone who aids an illegal to get aid, everyone, legitimate or not, that is of Hispanic origin is refused aid of any kind until the perpetrators are found, and punished. Mexico's economic woes are NOT America's fault. The total fault for the plight of the Mexican people is with their government and those who hold any power over the common people.