Whats the best eyeliner pencil?

Question

All my eyeliner pencils are alright but, it doesn't last for long so i find myself redoing it every hour. can you recommend one which will last all day?

Personal experience please not adverts which say it works.

Answer 1

covergirl perfect blend!!!!!!

it last forever and it goes on smooth, and it comes out really nice and even! plus it only cost like a buck fifty!

Answer 2

the mac power point eye pencil is absolutly the best eyeliner ever.

its waterproof; no smudge; easy to apply & stays on all day.

$14.50

Answer 3

Sephora's sparkly and non-sparkly eye liner!!!! it works great n its soooooo amazingly cute!! Its 8 $!!!! I luv luv luv it!!

Answer 4

Mac.

its really dark and stays on forever.

but its too expensive for me...

so i use covergirl. and i wear A TON

of eyeliner...and it doesnt come off.

Answer 5

Make Up Forever! you can find it at sephora.com they have great colors and stay for long periods without giving you the Panda look.

I love their "Aqua Eyes" color! (bluish)

Answer 6

Barry M is my favourite brand, but it can be hard to find (well, I livein England). And some products are quite expensive.

Answer 7

avon works really well for me.

http://shop.avon.com/shop/product.asp?pf...

Answer 8

I use Revelon Colorstay Eyeliner in black. I found when doing my makeup years ago pencils would fade and you'd have to re-apply all the time. This is very thick and makes a defined line. It's not a pencil, it's a roll up and you can buy it at Wal-Mart or your local grocery / pharmacy. I have been using this for years! Good luck!

Answer 9

Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil.

They come in really cool colors, and glide on wonderfully. They're so soft, and mine always stays on all day. It's definitely worth it to have a couple of these around.

Answer 10

kk u NEED the, Urban Decay 24/7 glide on pencil liner.... IT IS AMAZING!!! if you get it in the blackest black (like i have) you will get dramaticly beautiful results... I swear to you this stuff rocks cuz it really does stay on ALL DAY LONG! You can buy it at ULTA that is where i got mine or most likely on line for $17! Trust me it is the BEST eyeliner i have ever used in my life and my friend says she LOVES how it looks...

Hope i helped and trust me you'll love it!♥:)

Answer 11

annabell eyeliner stays on ALL day long. and its only 8 bucks!

Answer 12

I use Rimmel London kohl pencil eyeliner because the rest would always pull on my eyelids when I tried to apply them. It lasts okay for me but I really prefer liquid because it stays in place 5 times longer than pencil. I have Maybelline unstoppable eyeliner in pewter and it stayed in place through both going tubing on the river and crying.  

Answer 13

rimmel is ok and its cheaper than nost so u'll spend less even if u replace it often

Answer 14

You know, it may not be your eye liner pencil itself that isn't lasting. It may be something else causing it to rub off. Wash your face, apply moisturizer if needed but don't use too much (!), or else your makeup will smear right off. Wait about 10 minutes or so to let the moisturizer dry all the way. Then apply your makeup. Foundation and concealer and use powder to set it. Apply your liner, but don't use too much. Find a darker color if you always feel the need to apply too much. Even something as simple as living in a humid climate could cause it to smear/run. Crying and sweating can as well.

I like Mary Kay's. It's in a twistie pencil. You don't need to sharpen it. Another one I like is New York Color and it's less than $3 at Walmart. I like to put mine on before applying shadow. The shadow will set it more.