When a person earns 200 million should they be required to give all future earnings to the government? Why or?

Question

why not?

Answer 1

No!!!  They earned it, they have a right to keep it.

If you had to give all of your future earnings to the government, what would be your incentive to keep working?

Answer 2

Your joking right? No, that would lead to a complete collapse of the economy.

If I had to give all of my earnings to the government...WHY would I bother to work? Perhaps as a hobby to support those that haven't put in the time and the sweat it takes to succeed.

Hope this helps.

Answer 3

Of course not!  I can't think of a faster way to stymie investment or business development than such a confiscatory tax as that.  It would crash the economy immediately and totally.

Answer 4

Giving it to the government would be the equivalent of communism.

Reject the politics of envy.

Eating the rich will NOT make this country better, only worse off.

Answer 5

LOL, NO!

Why punish someone for doing well?

Answer 6

Now that is a great idea!!  Tax the rich out of existence.  That way we won't have to be bothered by the fact that they only pay about 50% of their income in taxes.

Answer 7

ANY PERSON Should NEVER be required to do anything in terms of personal taxes.  the government should just impose a set tax on products we buy. It makes more sense.  If the rich wants to splurge, then all they have to do is pay the products tax. simple!