When people say "Everyone has a unique personality, and no one can replace them" can they be replaced?

Question

Maybe not physically, but personality wise?

Example: A person's natal chart. If they died, and maybe years later, someone was born with the exact same chart as they did, would they have the same personality?

Do personalities become "reborn" in astrology? Meaning the stars, planets, houses etc. will line up at the same places again and again as time passes?

Just a thought.

Answer 1

I think your personality isn't just about charts and what stars were shining the night you were born.  A big part of your personality is formed in your first three years of life and whatever experiences you had during that time..  good or bad..  help to make us who we are today.  If you were lucky enough to have nice parents who nurtured you, then you will probably be better equipped to make smart decisions and have a bright future than someone born to addicts.  If someone was born years later with all the same astrological details didn't have the same family and experiences than you, then they would still be a very different personality.

Answer 2

Part of who you are is also formed by your life experiences; whether you have had hardships that have made you stronger (or weaker), or people who have influenced you in some way etc. So if two people have the exact same natal chart but live in different times, circumstances and experiences, they will be different. They could be similar, of course, but there are just too many variables to give you two people who think and react exactly the same.

Answer 3

do some studies on twins seperated at birth. I think that's the closest you're going to get for a true answer to this question.

Answer 4

nobody can b exactly like u (personality wise) u see  astrology is just like kind of describing some part of you not necessarily you. also not everyone is exactly how they r describe in astrology however u can b convinced that u r making ur personality change, but no no one can b exactly like you.

Answer 5

yes. i believe the same chart could repeat over again, but not with the same exact degrees in each house. I also believe that the personality is influenced by living conditions, family influence and the signs in the family, as well as the experiences we go through in life. but yes, I believe in the same chart recurring. i also believe that we could have chart doubles out there, people with the planets in the same houses. a new baby is born on average every 5 minutes on earth. that is not to say that someone couldn't be born at the exact same time as someone else in another part of the world. can we really say it would be impossible for a chart double to exist somewhere?

but then again, you are talking to someone who believes in recarnation of the soul into a new body. so i am an open mind.