Where does hermaine taylor rank among p4p and fighter in his class?

Question

Where does hermaine taylor rank among p4p and fighter in his class?

Answer 1

I assume that you mean Jermain Taylor and not Hermaine.  Well, since he is now fighting in the super middleweight division, I would definately rank him in the top 10.  He only has one fight at that weight, which was a loss to Kelly Pavlik, but he looked good in that loss and showed that he can fight well at that weight.  I'd like to see him face Jeff Lacy next, but there's word that Lacy may be retiring.  As far as pound for pound goes, Taylor is not even in the discussion at this point.  A year or 2 ago, he was in the top 10, but now that he's lost twice to Kelly Pavlik, he dropped out.

Answer 2

In the super middleweight divison Jermain Taylor is ranked 10 by ring magizine. However i think it is probably one of the top 5 guys in the weight class.

Answer 3

There is not allot in the super middleweight division to compare him too so he would make the top 10 in his division

But would he be on the pound for pound list? h**l no! The guy beat Hopkins then fought a bunch of little jr middleweights then lost when he finally fought a big Middleweight and has done nothing since then.

There are too many other guys to even consider before adding Taylor to the list.

1. Manny Pacquioa

2. Antonio Margarito

3. Miguel Cotto

4. Juan Manuel Marquez

5. Israel Vazquez

6. Kelly Pavlik

7. Joe Calzaghe

8. Shane Mosley

9. Ivan Calderon

10. Christian Mijares

And theres a bunch more that make up the top 15 before I would think of adding Taylor.