Which Championship Scramble is the worst and why?

Question

Raw: CM Punk (Champion), Rey Mysterio (replacing John Cena), Kane, Batista & John "Bradshaw" Layfield

ECW: Mark Henry (Champion), Finlay, Matt Hardy, Chavo Guerrero & the Miz

SD: Triple H (Champion), Jeff Hardy, M.V.P., Shelton Benjamin & THE Brian Kendrick

Answer 1

Smackdown because there is only 2 good people in it. Triple H and Jeff Hardy.Shelton Benjamin, MVP and The Brian Kendrick should be replaced by The Great Khali, Vladimir Kozlov and The Undertaker. (If Edge wasn't injured then him)  

Answer 2

Its actually good.Raw isn't good and also ecw but it would be good

Answer 3

I THINK ECW SCRAMBLE MATCH IS WORST BECAUSE

THEY HAVE SUCH IDIOTS LIKE CHAVO GUERRERO,

FINLAY & THE MIZ I WAS HOPING FOR JOHN MORRISON,

TOMMY DREAMER & EVAN BOURNE BUT IT WAS NOT

HAPPENED THAT IS SO SICK & BORING MATCH OF THE

UNFORGIVEN THATS IT

Answer 4

ECW, because only two of those would make a mediocre Champion, and one of them isn't even the Champion.

Raw's is definitely the best though.

Answer 5

Smackdown, there is only really two legit championship contenders, the current champ HHH and Jeff Hardy, MVP and Shelton are still a little bit away (but could be there very soon) and well The Brian Kendrick is a mid-carder at best.

Answer 6

RAW

It is totally random with undeserving contenders.

Answer 7

SD, no real super stars other than Jeff Hardy and Triple H can hold the WWE for more than 3 months and still have fans cheer for them. M.V.P Shelton Benjamin and Brian Kendrick can't hold a title for more than a month and be defending the title every week. Triple H and Jeff Hardy can defend the Title if they want, but choose not to.

Answer 8

ecw because they all suk

Answer 9

As much as i hate to say it, ECW. One of the main points is because of the superstars in the scramble.

   Chavo Guerrero - Chavo is one of the best wrestlers in the business. There will be some f**s disagreeing with this but face the facts, Titles held by chavo, 7. Titles held by the dumb s***s that don't recognize chavo for how great he is 0. Chavo may not be my favorite superstar but he is one h**l of a competitor and i would love to see him as champ again.

  

   Finlay - Finlay has had numerous title opportunities but this time i think he will succeed. Finlay has competed in the 2006  and the 2007 money in the bank but has come up short in both. In his years of wwe, he is only a one time U.S. champion. I'd hate him to remain like that when he retires. Finlay has mainly competed as a mid-carder for the last few months and has not had many title opportunities. The scramble is his chance.

   The Miz - If you hate the miz, go **** yourself then watch an episode of the dirt sheet. The miz is a funny guy and a great wrestler. This is one of miz's few major matches (The ECW championship is the only title worthy of wwe) and i think that he will pull this one out.

   Matt Hardy - The fan favorite for this match has been in contention for the ecw title for a few weeks now. How great will it be to watch mat earn his first major title in wwe (U.S. title is mid level and cruiserweight title is like, WTF?). I have been watching matt's matches for years now and i cant get enough of his matches. I would love to see him walk out of unforgiven as the new ECW champion.

Mark Henry - Mark has been with wwe for years now and this is his first title run. Mark is a bit over hyped and in my opinion shouldnt be in the uppercard. I was appalled to see henry with his hand raised at night of champions. Its not like i didnt see it coming. He got drafted to ECW and was the only Ecw guy in the tripple threat. I want to see a new champion. Mark has had his run, time for Miz's reign ;P

  From what you have just read, it might look like ive made everyone seem good. Point is everyone in that match is good. I wish i could say the same for the roster. Ever since the 2007 draft, ecw has been dead. Major hits were sandman gone to raw and released later that year. Sabu released, a true legend of ecw. marcus cor von gone. Benoit double murder suicide case. (may he, nancy and daniel R.I.P.) RVD gone. it is because of these changes that ecw has not had a good roster since sabu was around. the roster we have now has no exitement to it. All the ECW originals except for tommy dreamer are gone. we now have guys like super crazy *throws up* Tony atlas returning *throws up again* the ecw title belt getting raped *throws up for the third time* Matt striker and todd grisham on commentary! **** THAT! because of all this, ecw's roster and unforgiven scramble match officially sucks.

        R.I.P. ECW!

Answer 10

I have an issue with all 3 of them but to be honest, I'm not really complaining.

I like the fact that Smackdown is keeping Undertaker and Edge out the title race, but it seems like Triple H is just there to squash all of his opponents. I still don't understand why Big Show isn't in for Jeff Hardy or Brian Kendrick.

For the ECW scramble, I can't understand why The Miz is there instead of John Morrison, and why Chavo is there instead of Evan Bourne.

I would have rather seen someone else instead of Mysterio as it kills the Kane storyline, probably bringing in Big Show from Raw for one night only could have been a better idea.

Answer 11

ECW, not much good people.

I'd want Miz to win though.

Answer 12

I'd say Smackdowns.  Raws is fairly star studded, which is the way this gimmick should be.  ECW's roster isn't exactly packed with marquee players, and considering the rest of the roster, excluding a few possible interchangeable's like Morrison or Bourne, this is a very solid representation of their main event draws.

Smackdown's just seems like it's going through the motions.  Looking at this, we know that Triple H is going to retain.  As much as I love guys like Kendrick, Benjamin, and even MVP, they're not ready for a World Title run.  I'm not saying these guys couldn't be built to be in that position.  Anyone who makes a claim like that with both CM Punk and Mark Henry holding straps is a blind idiot, bur right now Kendrick is a solid worker and solid on the mic, but he's done nothing but squash locals and new names since revamping his image, and the WWE's doing right by MVP, considering they could be shoving him down our throats, but instead they've opted for a slow build, and slow builds are good.  Slow builds allow us to become hungrier and hungrier for an inevitable star, instead of shoving them down our throats, and yes, there is a difference between pushing and shoving.  Shelton...well, I think he's a phenomenal athlete, but he just doesn't have the charisma or crowd connection to make it to the upper crust in my eyes.  But, then again, many said the same thing about Mark Henry, and currently he's one of my favorite brand champions.  Does it have anything to do with his wrestling?  Heck no, he's improved, and last week proved that, but HECK no.  What draws me in to Henry is tha the is an engaging heel character, and he has the charismatic chops, the reputation, and the look to pull off the character he's portraying.  I've said it on here before, and I'll say it again, pro wrestling hasn't been about wrestling since the late 70's.  It's all about a hook.  Right now, I don't consider Shelton's gimmick to be engaging enough to sway people to put him over as a main eventer.

Anyway, I'm off track.  Smackdown's looks like a 20 minute squash, plain and simple.  The only person in it that has an inkling of hope of willing this is Jeff Hardy, and I just don't see it happening.

Answer 13

RAW championship scramble is the worst....why is batista in the scramble? What did he do to deserve a title shot...why is he one of the main evens in all the PPV'S?

Answer 14

all 3... because...