Which Fantasy Football Trade would be better

Question

Which trade combo would be the best:

1) I give up Steven Jackson, Reggie Wayne, and Torry Holt for Adrian Peterson, Maurice Drew-Jones, and Roddy White

or

2) I give up Steven Jackson, Reggie Wayne, Torry Holt, and Kevin Smith for Adrian Peterson, Maurice Drew-Jones, and Anquan Boldin

This is a keepers league.

Answer 1

Trade numbah 2 no question. The trades are essentially the same the difference being you'll be giving up a rookie RB in addition, but you'll get a better WR. Atlanta sucks they have no QB so you don't want Roddy White. Boldin is an excellent option However since you're losing Wayne and Holt and getting Boldin, I hope you're stacked up at WR.  Either do #2 or don't trade, but don't do #1

Answer 2

My question is, why are you wanting to trade those players at all?  You have reliable players undisputed starters that are consistent every week.  AP could be an injury risk.  MJD is in a RBBC.  Boldin is the WR2 on his team and is also an injury risk.

I say no NO to both trades.  Steven Jackson will have a better year than last year.  Reggie Wayne is also going to be putting up ridiculous stats.  Tory Holt is the WR1 on his team and is a great complement to your team as the WR2 on your team.

Also, it is way too early to be trading period.  You haven't seen anything in the preseason and the regular season is still a month away.  Be patient and keep your stars.  You will win by watching the waiver wire.  Great players will emerge like last year. AP, Roddy White, Wes Welker, and Ryan Grant are great examples of that.  Look for them all season long.  That is how you win.  The draft only gets you started.  Every experienced FFB player will tell you that the team you start with will not be the team you end up with at the end of the season.

Thumbs up to those who agree.

Answer 3

If you do any I'd do #1

Answer 4

Dont do number 1. Your giving ip a star RB and 2 awsome WR's for 1 star plaryers for 2 okay players. I think deal 2 is alittle better but I think you lose in both traedes