Which Party dress for my girls?

Question

We are going to my MIL 60th birthday party and it will be formal. So which dress do you like best?

My daughter's are 12 and 7. My MIL likes it when they match, because she thinks it really cute so we decided we would put them in matching clothes.

Which one?

http://www.gap.com/browse/product.do?cid=6300&pid=582001

OR

http://www.target.com/Girls-Flower-Stripe-Dress-White/dp/B0017JUCS8/qid=1217197918/ref=br_1_33/602-3145591-6586231?ie=UTF8&node=145232011&frombrowse=1&pricerange=&index=tgt-mf-mv&field-browse=145232011&rank=pmrank&rh=&page=1

Answer 1

the one from the gap is really cute.

Answer 2

I absolutely love the Gap! I shop at the Gap for my kids too. Mostly baby Gap. I personally like the second one because I think it is absolutely adorable, and would look great on a 12 year old and a 7 year old!

Answer 3

The white one from the Gap. Since the party is formal, this dress seems to fit.  I think it is gorgeous! Have fun at the party :)

Answer 4

The Gap one seems more formal. But I like both :)

Answer 5

I like the first one for a formal party.  The second one seems more casual.  Cute dress!

Answer 6

http://www.gap.com/browse/product.do?cid... This is my choice. It's a little dressier. Neither dress is very formal though.

Answer 7

The first one is really cute for two girls white may get stained easier but u can get stain remover and have a great dress

(GAP is always more prettier :) )

Answer 8

the first one is so much prettier

Answer 9

I would go with the GAP one because GAP clothes have quality.

Answer 10

I like the dresses from target, there is a lot of color, and white gets ruined to easily.

Answer 11

GAP

Answer 12

Definately the gap dress. The other one is too mature looking.

Answer 13

targethave really nice clothes all mosthalf of my clothes are from target and cool back to school clothes my clothes match at target

Answer 14

the first is more elegant

second is more casuall

i would go with the firstt

Answer 15

gap!!! the second 1 looks more like an adult shirt

Answer 16

http://www.dillards.com/webapp/wcs/store...

here try this

it comes in pink and black

if you dont like it just look around on the page

get your daughters to agree but dont make them MATCH maybe either the same dress in different colors or the same color but different style (the latter is better)

because of their ages they are not going to want to match and will probably argue about it so compromise on it

also a 12 and 7 yr old matching exactly is ridiculous

both of the dresses you picked are not appropriate for your age range or a party (white will get covered in dirt and cake) and the green one is just icky

Answer 17

the white one from gap is way better

Answer 18

I bought the same gap dress for my daughter. It's gorgeous. Go for that one!

God Bless!

Answer 19

I prefer the Second one because it has color. The first one is white which depending on how messy your kids are might not be a good thing at a formal birthday party cause then if they have accident then it will be so noticeable, but if you girls are really careful and do not have these kindof accidents then I would put them in the first one. I just have two sisters that are close to that age and the 12 yo will be fine but the 7 yo might have a accident.. But again I like the second one because it has more color..Good luck!

Answer 20

I like the more colorful dress, but they are both very pretty.

What do your daughters think?  Does your 12 year old like dressing like her younger sister?