Which QB would u rather have starting on ur team?

Question

Donovan McNabb or Marc Bulger?

keep in mind that....

-Bulger has a new good offensive coordinator. he is 100% recovered. he has his #1 blocker (Pace) back now and cbssports.com has said that pace will "make a huge difference for Bulger and help him become a No. 1 QB once again."

-McNabb is now completely recovered from ACL injury. the team site says his throw is 100% back and he is working out consistently.

so... with those in mind... who would u rather have as ur starting QB? i have Bulger on my team and have been offered McNabb for him

Answer 1

I go with McNabb here.  While it is only a matter of "when" rather than "if" McNabb will get hurt, he is one of the single most explosive fantasy players when starting.  McNabb is the type of player that can single handedly win you a game through a out of this world performance.  Bulger on the other hand is decent and has good games, but he throws a lot of interceptions (which typically translate to negative fantasy points in most leagues) and has a much lower ceiling than McNabb.

So basically ride McNabb as long as you can, but bare in mind he requires a reasonable back-up to cover you once he misses time due to injury (Arizona QB, Culter, Delhomme... they would all fit the bill here).  You can scoop up a decent QB to fill for you while McNabb is out.  If you are lucky, McNabb returns just in time to lead the charge through your fantasy playoffs.  

Bulger is the type of player that can help you put together a decent season, but McNabb is the type of player that can win you a championship.

Answer 2

i would stick with bulger

Answer 3

keep bulger

unless more is added to the trade, he's better