Which Qb should i start in week one?

Question

Aaron Rodgers, he's versing minnisotas defense OR

Derek Anderson, he's versing Dallas defense

Answer 1

That's a tough one.

Both are playing at home and against top 5 defenses in the league.

I would give the advantage in this choice to Rodgers though.

The reason being the Packers are great at home, and they play the Vikings twice every year.

They know how to prepare for the Vikings and have plenty of film to study on their tendancies.

Rodgers is NOT practically a rookie. He has been preparing himself for this situation for 3 years now. He knows the offense just as well as Favre ever did and will be able to run it just as good.

The Browns rarely find themselves playing the Cowboys, and will have a much harder time preparing for them.

So take Rodgers in front of the Packer Backers in his home field debut as the starter.  

Answer 2

Without a doubt start Derek Anderson.  Cleveland is going to have one of the most potent offenses this year.  Winslow, Edwards, Lewis, Jurevicious you will be just fine.  Rodgers is practically a rookie and going against division opponent he will choke.  Go with the proven guy Anderson

Answer 3

derek anderson has better o-line than rodgers and rodgers is facing probably the best d-line in the nfl  

Answer 4

well I think the Dallas Cowboys defense will do worst then last year.

So I would pick Derek Anderson