Which RB should i trade?

Question

I really need help at the QB spot (my 2 starters are delhomme and garrard) so, i wanted to trade one of my RB's to hopefully get peyton manning. Which Rb should i trade? My 3 starting RB's are Clinton portis, ryan grant, and adrian peterson.... But i think its obvious i wont trade AP. Who should i trade... grant or Portis. I am worried portis will get hurt, and i am worried grant will be a fluke.

Answer 1

Grant nor Portis will get you Peyton Manning.

And I would argue that Garrard and Delhomme both could have better years than Manning.  You can't always go on past success...Delhomme had a rating of 111 before getting hurt last year and Garrard was in the Top 5 for the season in rating.

Stick with what you have and ride it out.

Answer 2

If I was the other guy I wouldnt trade Payton for either one. If you dont want to trade AP you would be better to mix a WR in with one of them

Answer 3

you should be worried about AP geting hurt as well

The man is as fragile as a china doll. he has never made it through a full season in college or the pros so far

He is the only guy you could trade to get P.Manning. If you want to trade one of the other guys instead go after Brees or Big Ben

Answer 4

I think that you wont get Payton for even both of them so I would trade Ryan Grant for someone like Hasselback or even Chad Pennington.  

Answer 5

Flip A Coin Dude. Those 2 Could Go Either Way, Grants For Real And Portis Injury Prone. Keep Em And Hope Jake D Stays Healthy. Good Luck To Ya This Season.

Answer 6

Don't do anything.  Never worry about somebody getting hurt because it could happen to anyone.  Heck, Manning has a bad knee right know.  What happens if he gets hit on that knee in the first game?

If you have concerns about Portis and Grant it's better to keep both of them because you may need the depth as well as coverage for your bye weeks.  Delhomme and Garrard should do OK for you anyway.

Answer 7

Theres no way your trading grant or portis for peyton

with grant or portis you could maybe land anderson, garcia, or palmer  

Answer 8

If you can pull off a trade with grant for a good QB go for it. Grant had a good year last year due to the fact that their opponents let him run in order to stop the pass and they always had the lead going into the second half and just ran it in the second half. This year GB's passing game will be suspect with an unproven QB. Teams will most likely focus more on Ryan Grant and stop the run. Also GB will probably not score as much this year meaning they will have to continue to throw the ball in the second half giving Grant less opportunities.