Which Rimmel Mascara?

Question

Can anyone recommend either Xtreme Lash Mascara or Lash Maxxx from Rimmel (both have comb wands)? I'm thinking between those two because I love comb mascaras and I need a mascara to seperate/define my eyelashes and make them longer/curlier? Does anyone have any other Mascara suggestions (with comb wands though)? Also, if I do get either of the Rimmel ones, should I opt for normal or waterproof? I don't really have any preferences it's just that I've noticed in the past that normal mascara flakes off and doesn't tend to last as long (concerning the curl) whereas waterproof does but it's really hard to take off and some people say that its chemicals cause your eyelashes to weaken. Does waterproof affect your eyes at all? And does anyone have first hand experience with the two Rimmel mascaras whether or not the waterproof versions are hard or easy to remove? [Sorry for asking so many questions!]

Answer 1

I've used lash maxxx in non waterproof and the comb is really good (: it thickens and lengthens, and if you heat up your eyelash curler with a hairdrier, they will stay curled for heaps longer :D

With waterproof, you've said pretty much all the pros and cons that i could think of =P but also some people say that waterproof makes your lashes longer because it is waxier.

If you have an eye makeup remover, i would suggest getting the waterproof version (:

hope i helped!

Can anyone answer mine plz? (:

http://au.answers.yahoo.com/question/ind...