Which Team is more Disappointing The Detroit Tigers or The Cleveland Indians?

Question

lol It should be The Tigers and Indians Fighting for The AL Central

Answer 1

The Tigers

They have the best team on paper (even better than the Sox and Yanks). They added Studs like Miguel Cabrera to their already good offense, and they also added D-Train to their pitching staff. They should be top 3 in the American League with the Roster they have.

Answer 2

Tigers were suppose to kic there division instead there getting kicked

Answer 3

I'm a Tiger fan. They are the biggest flop. Don't know who's really worse, my brothers Yanks or my Detroit cream puffs.

PS-Can't stand Mets, come on Phillies!

Answer 4

Cleveland. They have worse record but similar expectation.

Disappointment depends on the fans. My list of disappointment:

1. Braves

2. Indians

3. Tigers

4. Mariners

5. Yankees

Answer 5

Easily its the Tigers All Star at almost every position and they're what? 4 or 5 games under .500? When they traded for Cabrera and the D-Train they were with out a doubt everyone's pick to go to the World Series but, they haven't lived up to the hype

Answer 6

you're probably right about both of them but you can leave my Cleveland out of this babee!!

Answer 7

The Indians by far.  I actually thought they had a chance to win the division while the Tigers are about where I believed they would be without any pitching.

Answer 8

The Detroit Tigers

Answer 9

The Indians without question.  They went from 96 wins and one game of the World Series, to last place, with essentially the same team.  The Tigers looked good on paper, but that doesn't always bode success.

Answer 10

Detroit. They were supposed to be the best team in baseball. The Indians were just expected to be mediocre.

Answer 11

I'm going to go with the Indians, because CC is likely to never come back.

Answer 12

How about the Seattle Mariners, the biggest joke in baseball when they should be contending.

Answer 13

Detroit Tigers...just look at all the big money and big names. The Indians dealt C.C. and tried to make a move for the future.

Answer 14

Has to be the Tigers.  Everybody, and I mean Everybody had them going to the world series after the off season moves they made.  

Answer 15

It depends on who you root for. Yeah, let's fight for number 3.  

Answer 16

I would have to say the Indians. From 1 game from the world Series last year to a big disappointment this season.

Answer 17

It's more disappointing about the Tigers. They were almost sure to be in the playoffs but their pitching wasn't really good in the beginning of the year and the so called superstars of the team started batting almost around the All Star Break, so too late.  

Answer 18

The Tigers

people were predicting them to win the d**n WS!

and the White Sox were supposed to be compeating for 4th place right?

We should stop predicting things....it never works out that way.

Answer 19

tigers. everyones choice to win the world series. didnt turn out too well

Answer 20

Definitely the Tigers. Everyone thought they would being doing so well.

Answer 21

lol Baseball is one unpredictable sport, isn't it? When the Tigers got Miguel Caberea and D. Willis, I thought they could do no wrong... until they started playing. They were behind from Opening Day and never caught up since. The Cleveland Indians were another team I thought would at least be a contender but instead we got the Minnesota Twins (who doesn't even have Tori Hunter or Johan Santana) and the Chicago White Sox fighting for the AL Central.

They're both (Indians and Tigers) big disappointments but let's face it, it's the Detroit Tigers who have been disappointing ever since they lost the World Series against the St. Louis Cardinals. Worst, the Tigers traded Pudge Rodriguez for a reliever I can't even remember and the Indians lost C.C. Sabathia.