Question:

Which Trade Should I make?

by  |  earlier

0 LIKES UnLike

Trade A:

He gets: Derek Jeter

I get: Cristian Guzman

Trade B:

He gets: Jose Reyes

I get: Rafiel Furcal and Pladicico Polanco

My Lineup:

R Martin , C

B Molina (R), C

J Loney, 1B

J Votto (R), 1B

A Casilla, 2B

A Ramirez, 3B

J B. Reyes, SS

D Jeter (R), SS

J Edmonds, OF

K Fukudome, OF

M Kemp, OF

J Damon (R), OF

J Giambi, U

PITCHERS:

B Lyon

Cliff Lee

D Matsuzaka

D Haren

J Maine

T Lilly

T Hudson

J Lester (R)

T Percival (R)

His Team:

G Soto, C

A Pujols, 1B

P Polanco, 2B

M Reynolds, 3B

C Guzman, SS

R Furcal (R), SS

J Upton, OF

M Ordonez, OF

N McLouth, OF

J Bruce (R), OF

Miguel Cabrera, U

PITCHERS:

A Galarraga

B Lidge

G Floyd

G Sherrill

J Garland

J Papelbon

Z Greinke

B Sheets (R)

B Jenks (R)

J Weaver (R)

S Kazmir (R)

 Tags:

   Report

5 ANSWERS


  1. Dont trade Jeter! What are you a coke head?


  2. I would definitely make Trade B, because even though Jose Reyes is an All-Star, Polanco and Furcal are both great quality players. Polanco is the most consistent hitter in Baseball, and averages a strike out only every 26.5 at bats, a MLB best! He is batting .316 on the year, and in his last 10 games is batting .390. Furcal has been on the DL for quite some time, but will be great when he comes back. He is batting .366 on the year (134 AB) with 5 HR's and 16 RBI's

  3. keep reyes, You need more then Polanco and Furcal I'd demand more HR if I'm giving up reyes (who is on pace for 20 anyway)

    F jeter

  4. neither!

  5. Trade A has no benefit to you; I wouldn't even consider it.

    Trade B looks nice on paper but I wouldn't pull the trigger. Furcal's been out a long time with his back and that's probably the toughest injury for a SS to bounce back from, pardon the pun.

    If you were to make any deals, I'd suggest attempting to strengthen your weakest area by far, your OF.

Question Stats

Latest activity: earlier.
This question has 5 answers.

BECOME A GUIDE

Share your knowledge and help people by answering questions.