Which Twilight book is your favorite?

Question

Twilight

New Moon

Eclipse

Or

Breaking Dawn

My favorite book was eclipse but i like them all the best one fore me would have to be eclipse

Answer 1

Twilight most definitely.

It is the basis and starting point to Bella and Edward's whole relationship!

Answer 2

The only one that I thought was good at all was Twilight.

In Twilight, Bella was a strong, intelligent heroine. In New Moon she was a helpless sap. Honestly, it took her months to recover enough to even talk to anybody after her boyfriend of a few months broke up with her. That is pathetic. What kind of example does that set for girls? "If you get dumped, it is the end of the world"?

In Eclipse, she was disgustingly needy. She wouldn't even let Edward out of her sight! All because he left her once. What happened to strong, independent Bella?!

Breaking Dawn was like a several hundred page (poor) fan fiction written by a 13 year old girl. All of Stephenie's strong characters were utterly drained of life.

Answer 3

i really love all of them but

first: eclipse; now that i have read breaking dawn i have a better respect and perspective for jacob

second: twilight and breaking dawn; really hard to choose, but i liked twilight a lot, and breaking dawn was great but i really do not like renesmee at all, i think she ruined the whole book.

third: new moon; team edward.

Answer 4

Breaking Dawn. It was amazing.

Answer 5

Eclipse had the best plot. Twilight was way too fluffy, it was 300 pags of fluff 100 pages of plot. Same with Breaking Dawn (except it was 700 pages of stupidty and fluff, and then 100 pages of plot then in the end wasn't a plot after all). New moon was amazing because Edward wasn't in it and Jacob was.

Answer 6

i would say it is a toss up between Twilight and Breaking Dawn....when it comes down to it i think i would say Twilight because i like all the mystery at the beginning and how exciting it is when she slowly begins to understand what Edward and his family really are!!

Answer 7

My prefrence order:

1) Breaking Dawn - Only th bit from jakes point of view. hillarious

2) Eclipse - really good plot, and jake still had a fighting chance.

3) New moon - Here we get to know my favourite character Jake.

4) Twilight - Pffft. ( A good book, though fustratingly corny at some parts) But not enough of Jake.

jake jake jake

obsessed much?

hehe... yea.

Answer 8

Twilight, I thought was by far the best. Although the start was a little bit boring, I loved the ending, when stuff started to happen. It was the beginning to Edward/Bella and I loved it!

Next, would come New Moon. I thought it was a far cry from Twilight, and that Bella over-reacted about Edward leaving way too much, but (like Twilight) the ending was my favourite part.

Not far behind, would be Eclipse. Although I can't really remember what happened anymore, I thought that it was pretty good and worth reading.

Way, way, way behind would be Breaking Dawn. I'm sorry that I have to disagree with the people who loved it. I thought that the ending was way too happy, I really envisioned something else. Bella dying, perhaps? (Yes, I know I'm evil) Also, the characters did not seem like themselves and what was with Bella having a kid? It was way too weird. I also didn't like how there was all this build-up for the battle, and then there was no battle. I was a little disappointed, actually. (I'm sorry that i criticised it so much, I know I'd never be able to write like that, but I was really disappointed)

Answer 9

Oh my gosh thats tuff... I would say Twilight or New Moon, because in Breaking Dawn for the first half all they talked about was her last human experience on the honeymoon... And, Eclipse isnt as memorable in my mind... BUT I AM IN LOVE WITH ALL OF THEM!!! NO DOUBT!

Answer 10

my fave was twilight<3

Answer 11

twilight definitely... it is like the starting point of the relationship and has all the chemistry between edward and bella!

next would be eclipse... just because of the tent seen and page 460 (like my fav page in the novel)!

I wouldn't really like to pick a last one so i will put breaking dawn and new moon together... new moon i have started to appreciate, but the first time i read it i couldn't stand it there was like over 200 pages without edward and breaking dawn was just different even though i really loved the ending... in the end twilight only wins by a fraction above eclipse and eclipse only a fraction above the other two because i love them all!

Answer 12

From favorite to least favorite and some explanation:

1. New Moon- I love Jacob. Hands down.

2. Eclipse- Bella's choice was made, setting in stone the foundation for Breaking Dawn.

3. Twilight- A little too much Edward and Bella for my taste.

4. Breaking Dawn- Absolutely hated it.  

Answer 13

I love all of them, but I would have to say my favorite is Twilight. I love how Bella and Edward get to know eachother and fall in love. I usually like the beginnings better because everything is new and exciting. But I also like New Moon because you really get to know Jacob's character and how much Bella needs him as well as Edward.

Answer 14

hmm I REALLY love twilight i can read it over and over and over!!! i would have to say that i detest the middle of new moon...1. because Edward isnt in there...and 2. because i really dont like jacob...lol

but after twilight breaking dawn comes pretty close i really do like breaking dawn

but defs twilight *sigh* Edward Cullen  

Answer 15

in this order: Twilight, Breaking Dawn, Eclipse, New Moon