Which Victorian club do you think will take Chris Judd?

Question

Personally I hope Collingwood....

Answer 1

I think he will stay with the Eagles but if he does go I think it will be Collingwood.

I just heard he is definitely leaving and he is going to the highest bidder.

Answer 2

He barracked for Melbourne as a kid, does that have any pull nowadays? I mean, he's got his brownlow, he's got his flag, maybe supporter loyalty could rise to the top...

Answer 3

He is going to Carlton

Answer 4

Job done,... I think what you hope is what you  will get.   Just think,.....  why  would an elite player like Judd, who played in the 05 & 06 Grand finals consider clubs Like , Richmond, Carlton. Essendon or Melbourne, when he can join  Collingwood, the Country's most famous and elite club, who have the best young talent, and at worst will finish 4th this year.    At 24, his career would be over before, the above clubs reach Collingwood's  current position and future premiership potential .   Collingwood also is best placed with players available and likely to give the  club generous  salary cap relief, with the delisting of the likes of  Licuria,Holland Lonie Prestigiacomo Egan and plus possibly, the retirements of Buckley  Wakelin and Burns?

Not that its totally important, but without Lonie, it also means he could fit nicely into the black and white stripes, with his trademark No 3 .      You should also consider the existing West Coast influence at Collingwood ,coach  Malthouse, ex 2 time Eagles Premiership coach , and asst coach Mckenna,

ex Eagles captain and asst coach.    I just have the feeling this deal has been well planned and setup over a long period of time !

Answer 5

carlton

Answer 6

I'm a Pies supporter... and I think Judd is a superstar but I don't particually want him at Collingwood. If he comes, I won't be complaining but by the same token, not desperate for him to come to Pies.

Answer 7

Hawthorn

Answer 8

Carlton will break the bank, Elliott style to do anything to win. Remember the 80's?

Answer 9

He wants to play internationals, so he is going to the Melbourne Storm.  He'll be out on the wing replacing the retiring Matt Geyer and will run off Folau and Inglis to score a bag of tries

Answer 10

carlton-maybe, but i hope  we don't sell our soul to get him,at the end of the day he is still only 1 player in a team of 22

other candidates would have to be collingwood,essendon,richmond etc

Answer 11

Probably Carlton, they have the most to offer, as in draft picks

I think Hawthorn would be an attractive choice too.

Answer 12

Geelong - we're desperately short of quality mid-fielders at the moment.

Seriously - I don't think Pies need him.  They need more forward options than Sav and one more quality tall defender.

The prices quoted for him are way over the top, though Eddie Everywhere could always organise a special edition of Who Wants to be a Millionaire for injured footballers and arrange it so he won.  (Now there's a thought -  Footballer Millionaire!  The questions ... lol!  For a Million Dollars .... what should you do first, walk or chew gum?!  Oh dear another tangent)

Answer 13

I PERSONALLY HOPE HAWTHORN !!

how cool if we ( hawthorn  ) had juddy and buddy :O

hahaha

Answer 14

i think he is going to carlton

Answer 15

carlton has the first draft pick so they will take him

Answer 16

Carlton probably theve been named the favourites and theyll try to get him no matter what

Answer 17

Richmond.