Which aircraft would you prefer to see win a dogfight? Which one do you think would win?

Question

Consider the Su-37 Terminator, the Su-47 Berkut, and the F-22 Raptor. Assume all pilots are similarly skilled.

Answer 1

The F-22 of course... I help pay for it with taxes.

Answer 2

I think it will be the Sukhoi SU-47 Berkut.It features a pair of canard wings,a swept forward wing,and a 3-dimensional thrust vector control.The forward swept wing provides a very fast turning rate to shake off the enemy warplane,the wing also featured high manuoverbility at high angles of attack and at subsonic speeds while having a great anti spin characteristic compared to the 2 aircraft listed above.In a recent military simulation test held last year,the military did a simulation on how the F-22Raptor and the F-15 would would behave in intense dogfight against arch rival the Sukhoi SU-30MK.The results?F-15 being shot down 7/10 times,and the F-22 being shot down 6/10 times by Russian SU-30MK.

Answer 3

How about a Sopwith Camel.

Answer 4

The Terminator vs the Berkut would be a spectacle in the skies, two of the most maneuverable aircrafts in the world. Close call, I'd love to see the Su-37 win. The Terminator is a refined fighter while the Berkut is more of experimentation. Besides the Berkut doesnt quite have the extreme agility of the Su-37. For example the Kulbit is beyond the Berkut's capability.

And I'd always loved the Su-37 for Mikhail Simonov's dogfight challenge.

Victory of refinement over experimentation!!!

Answer 5

then it would be about speed