Which do you recommend, 1975 Port Ellen (24YO), 1977 Arbeg (21 YO) or 18 YO Higland Park?

Question

The Port Ellen is a Signatory bottling. I've had it for about 6 years.

Answer 1

What's a 1964 Port Ellen? We have one and we don't drink wine....

Answer 2

18 YO Higland Park   definitely definately definately

1975 Port Ellen          save it to 2015

1977 Arbeg (21 YO)    not for me (yuk)

but then my taste are different... I actually prefer something totally different: Champagne Aubry Brut Jouy-les-Reims Premier Cru

I really have no business answering this other than it popped up starred. I know so little... sigh (but I see others know less; I thought Port Ellen was a malt Scotch Whiskey)

Answer 3

Now I don't have my wine list beside me, so I don't know if you're goofing around or not, LOL!  If you're not, go with Port Ellen...the older the better, as far as wines go......Have a great weekend!!