Which fantasy baseball trade offer should I accept?

Question

I have two trade offers for CC. Sabathia.

Option A.

Manny Ramirez

Matt Kemp

Francisco Rodriquez

Option B.

Jake Peavy

Billy Wagner

Mike Lowell

My pitchers are great with the exception of Saito who is going on the DL. Both deals involve me giving up only Sabathia.

Which option should I accept??

Answer 1

if you must :  Option A

don't know your needs, however

Answer 2

Pick option A because you would get  a powerful hitter in Manny Ramirez who will give you major runs because Big Papi is coming back soon and also give you good average because he is consistent every year and also he would give tons of home runs. Then you get arguably the most dominant closer in the game n K-Rod he will get you lots of saves and they don't call him K-Rod for nothing so he will get you lots of saves as well and also it will give another arm until Saito comes back and you could even use Saito as trade bait when he returns. As for Kemp he is a useful bench player but if your bench is stacked you could just drop him but my advice would be to keep him.

Answer 3

take option A

Answer 4

Definetely option A. Here are Ramirez's projected stats: .290 BA, 30 homers, and 100 RBI's. Not bad, huh? He also has a great OPS considering how many times he walks. Here are Kemp's projected stats: .285 BA, 20 homers, 90 RBI's, 35-40 stolen bases, that's another star. And finally K-Rod. Here are the stats that he is on pace for: 0-3, 70 K's and a whopping 65 saves! I say go for it considering that all you're losing is Sabathia.

Answer 5

Option A

Manny and Kemp are better then Lowell and Peavy if you saw Peavy last night it was terrible. And K-Rod has 38 saves i believe, which is a record setting pace.

Answer 6

TAKE OPTION B PEAVY IA SERVIABLE STARTER AND LOWELL IS A GOOD 3RD BASEMAN

Answer 7

Trade A. Gives you two good outfielders, and a closer who's on track to break the single season record.

Answer 8

Trade A

It gives you Manny who is a good outfielder and Francisco Rodriguez who is on track to break the single season saves record. Matt Kemp isn't bad either. On trade b Peavy has been injured some this year so he hasn't been as effective as he hoped to be.