Which game in 2006 was of poorest umpiring quality?

Question

Out of the games I saw this year I think the umpiring in the Saint Kilda vs. Western Bulldogs game in round 21 was absolutely appalling. I'd like to know which game everybody else thinks was??

Answer 1

Just about every match the Swans won had the worst sort of umpiring I've ever seen.

Answer 2

All South Melbourne (oops) swans games the umpires let them win every week and they will on Saturday as well

Answer 3

the home n away game at subi sydney n westcoast.

Answer 4

That game. And

the game between Freo and St Kilda. The umps must be deaf, can't hear the siren!

Answer 5

The Grand Final.  Pathetic, IMO.

Answer 6

Too me , everygame was appaulling by the umpires, I mean how many free kicks do they want to give per game? Rules keep on changing for what reason I don't know. The umpires can not keep up with the changes, let alone the players. There must be a free kick count per game, per umpire and if they don't meet there quota, consequences would be met.

The game is going too soft, thanks to the umpires and the umpiring commitee. The tribunal system sucks and does not work fairly.

And finally, Andrew Dimetreo should stand down as he is letting this great game fall apart.

Answer 7

Daffy, don't you get sick of starting all of your hate rants about the Sydney swans with:

"South Melbourne (oops) swans"

You are obviously trying to wind Sydney fans up, but I can promise you most Sydney fans are very proud of the South Melbourne Heritage. Indeed, many of us, myself included lobbied the club to add the SMFC motif to the backs of their jumpers. So please go on with calling us South Melbourne if you like. Just drop the (oops) is just makes you look stupid, as you can see from all the thumbs down you get.