Which goalie do u think is better out of these 6.?

Question

Manny Legace-Blues

Chris Osgood-Red Wings

Marc-Andre Fluery-Penguins

Martin Brodeur-Devils

Marty Turco-Stars

Tim Thomas-Bruins

Answer 1

Brodeur

Legace

Turco

Fleury (who will be better than Brodeur)

Osgood

Thomas

Answer 2

Putting into considering the team he plays on, who gets the most out of his ability?

I think I will give the vote to Thomas, he's a former Nordique pick and played in Finland, plus he's got that old school mask!

Another reason behind my reasoning : The other goalies although great tend to have many more years of NHL experience and oftentimes know the shooters tendancies .. play on better teams (or at least have better D help)

Legace doesn't get the credit he deserves, but I am appaled that someone 5'9 wears 37inch pads. At that height he should be wearing 32's! Seems like an unfair advantage a la Barry Bonds

Answer 3

Hands down...Martin Brodeur.

Answer 4

Marty B is #1

Marty T is #2

& I'm glad Nabby didn't make your list.

Answer 5

Brodeur

Answer 6

In order..........

1. Martin Brodeur

2. Chris Osgood

3. Marty Turco

4. Manny Legace

5. Marc-Andre Fleury

6. Tim Thomas

Answer 7

1. Martin Brodeur

2. Chris Osgood

3. Manny Legace

4. Marty Turco

5. Marc Andre Fleury

6. Tim Thomas

Answer 8

Brodeur.

Turco in a distant second... although I'm going by Brodeur's history (how can you not bet on Brodeur... one bad playoff showig seems like a fluke to his career).  Turco was phenomenal this past post-season and as good as Osgood was he didn't hang out there like Turco did.

Brodeur

Turco

Legace

Osgood - good but he's like Giguere. People love him when   he's hot but he's not hot that much.

Fleury

Thomas

Answer 9

1. Martin Brodeur

2. Chris Osgood

3. Marty Turco

4. Marce-Andre Fluery

5. Manny Legace

6. Tim Thomas (he $ucks, and I'm a Bruins fan)

Answer 10

BRODEUR,, OSGOOD

Answer 11

Brodeur.  Fleury is good and getting better, but he's not there yet.  Osgood is your man from April onward, but before that he's ordinary.  Legace and Turco are overrated.  And Thomas hasn't proven anything yet -- not even what Legace and Turco have proven.

Answer 12

Brodeur

Thomas

osgood

Fluery

Turco

Legace

Answer 13

martin brodeur

Answer 14

MARTIN BRODUER ANY DAY OF THE WEEK. THATS WHY HE WON THE VEZINA

ALTHOUGH I DO THINK THEY ALL ARE GOOD PLAYERS. IM A DEVILS/ BRUINS FAN

Answer 15

obviously brodeur

Answer 16

6.Manny Legace-Blues

4.Chris Osgood-Red Wings

2.Marc-Andre Fluery-Penguins

5.Martin Brodeur-Devils

1.Marty Turco-Stars

3.Tim Thomas-Bruins

Sorry Broudeur....you didnt did that good this year:(

WHY WONT THEY TRADE HIM!

Answer 17

I'd have to say Fleury. He is an amazing young player and he was consistent throughout the season. Marty Turco put up a heck of a fight in the playoffs against the Wings so he deserves recognition as well. Osgood was a brick wall during the playoffs and the Stanley Cup Final but he didn't play as much during the regular season which is why I wouldn't vote him the best even though he was a big factor in winning the Cup. GO WINGS =)

Answer 18

1 . Marty B

2 . Osgood

3. Turco

4. Fleury

5. Thomas

6. Legace

Answer 19

Chris Osgood, Ozzie has proven he can be consistent and he has the talent to come alive at any time

Answer 20

Personally I'd take Turco... Many will diasagree, however I've always thought that his success has resulted in playing under a good system,  good coaches.

While he is a good goaltender, I fell Turco has the ability to steal more games

Answer 21

1. Martin Brodeur

2. Chris Osgood

3. Marty Turco

4. Marce-Andre Fluery

5. Manny Legace

6. Tim Thomas (he $ucks, and I'm a Bruins fan  Goal

Answer 22

Brodeur- Turco- Osgood- Fleury (but marching his way up)- Legace (hard to choose between him and Fleury.. but I think with Fleury's potential he wins out)- Thomas (career journeyman withone good year)

Answer 23

Manny Legace is the best goalie in the NHL!

Chris Osgoos

Marc-Andre Fluery

Tim Thomas

Marty Turco

Martin Brodeur

Answer 24

At this moment I'd have to say Brodeur, but down the road, Fleury and Turco would top this list (Brodeur is getting up there in years, and not sure how many years he can continue to play 70 games during the regular season).

Answer 25

door slam shut by Brodeur still remember that line  the 2nd best to me is Turco he was crazy against the sharks in 08 playoffs

Answer 26

1.Martin Brodeur-Devils

2.Chris Osgood-Red Wings

3.Marty Turco-Stars

4.Marc-Andre Fluery-Penguins

5.Tim Thomas-Bruins

6.Manny Legace-Blues

Answer 27

Brodeur, followed by Fluery

Answer 28

brodeur by far..but give fleury a couple years and he will be a great goalie too

Answer 29

1) Brodeur

2) Flurey

3) Turco

4) Osgood

5) Legace

6) Thomas

Answer 30

Brodeur.  Not even close.  He's in the same category of Plante, Sawchuk, Roy, etc.

Answer 31

Without a doubt Martin Brodeur. Whoever said fleury is the best is an ideot. I wont deny it, fleury is a very good goalie but when his +6 thighrise legpads are banned 2 years from now he will be a joke.