Which injured QB is more important to his team? Tom Brady or Peyton Manning?

Question

Which injured QB is more important to his team? Tom Brady or Peyton Manning?

Answer 1

Without Peyton Manning,the Colts had a terrible record,and he made them into contenders,eventually winning a Super Bowl,on the other hand,Tom Brady started with a team led by Drew Bledsoe who already gone to the Super Bowl

Answer 2

Right now it's Peyton Manning, but if Dwight Freeney and Bob Sanders were healthy then it would be Tom Brady.

Answer 3

This one is a toughy... Im gng to say Manning. The Colts need him.. then again the Pats would be nothin without Brady... so can it be a tie? :)

Answer 4

manning by a long shot

Answer 5

Manning just because he's an "on the field coach".  He read defenses so well and puts his players in the best possible position to exploit the defense that he see.  Though Tom Brady does this almost as well, the Patriots seems to be more talented and doesn't seem to rely as heavy on Brady as does the Colts.  The Colts would be nothing without Manning.

Answer 6

After watching the pats past 2 pre-season games im going to go with brady.

Answer 7

the pats probly could win a few without tom    but the colts are screwed if peyton goes down

Answer 8

Both teams would be nothing without Brady or Manning. A few years ago though when Brady was winning superbowls with less then I would of said Brady was more of a loss because no one else could do it like him and then the Colts had a better chance of a backup being successful with the kind of team they had surrounding Peyton. I don't know though... seeing how miserable the Patriots backups have been playing in his absence I would be tempted to say that Brady is more of a loss. I mean... god, Tom Brady is the best QB any of us have seen in our lives... maybe the best we will ever see.

Answer 9

Tom Brady

Answer 10

i think if you took both away each team would do alright not no 13-3 or 14-2 seasons but solid 10-6 11-5 seasons

Answer 11

For me definetly Tom Brady that team would not have won so many Superbowls if it wasnt for him...did you see his 2 backup qb playing in pre-season...hmmmm  

Answer 12

Manning, though it would be quite interesting to see the multi talented hefty lefty Jared Lorenzen in the regular season, scrambling like Mike Vick.

Answer 13

neither team needs them right now come on do you really think manning and brady need preseason or as i like to say exhibition games but when the season comes i woulds say the patriots need brady more

Answer 14

i think  tom brady but he will be back  before the season

Answer 15

great question...very hard to decide...i'll say brady because he has less weapons although the best weapon in moss. sorgi could run the ball with addai, then you have wayne, harrison and the tight end..so his chance for success is better.

Answer 16

payton, the colts would be nothing without him

Answer 17

Manning.

Answer 18

Brady