Which match of Unbeatens is a better fight Calzaghe-Pavlik or Cotto-Mayweather?

Question

And who wins and which is more likely to happen in your eyes

Answer 1

Cotto- May is the more competitive fight.

I think May wins- but barely, and I certainly would not put a large sum of money on it.

Calzaghe - Pavlik does not go past 6 rounds as Pavlik blugeons Calzaghe into submission.

If a close tactical boxing exhibition with little chance of a KO is preferable then Cotto- May is the better fight.

If a spectacular KO of an undefeated fighter is a better fight, then Pavlik - Calzaghe is better

Personally I'd like to see the KO

Answer 2

They are both good match ups.  Cotto/Mayweather would be the one most of the public, myself included would want to see.  Calzaghe/Pavlik will be the one Calzaghe gets his comeuppance, I don't think Joe will beat Pavlik.  Cotto/Mayweather would be tougher, I don't think even with Cotto's questionable chin that Mayweather could dominate Miguel, Floyd would have to try and peck away from a safe distance an pick Cotto apart for a decision.  I don't think he could avoid Cotto the whole fight, and this one would be interesting.  I like Mayweather in this one, but it would be a very dangerous fight for Floyd.

Answer 3

cotto-mayweather i think cotto could pull off an upset and i cant stand mayweather. i want forbes to beat de la hoya and de la hoya mayweather to fall through and i want cotto to fight him instead. if he won, which i think he can, maybe mayweather would finally stfu.

Answer 4

cotto-mayweather no doubt....better match up and its a fight many have wanted to see for quite some time

i dont think a calzaghe-pavlik match up would go the distance...if calzaghe was smart hed steer clear of pavlik because i could see that fight ending quick

Answer 5

Calzaghe Vs Pavlik : no doubt would be the better fight. If Kelly gets off a lucky punch like Hopkins did in the first round,forget it,Pavlik wins in round one. If i had to choose it would be Kelly Pavlik,but he would need a knockout,if not it would be Calzaghe by unanimous decision.

Cotto VS. Mayweather: Mayweather is the last great black fighter. This would be boring with a capital B. Mayweather would rule the ring and adjust to everything Cotto tried to do. It's that simple. Mayweather is a God when it comes to ringmanship.

Answer 6

Calz-Pav, by a mile is the better fight.  Mayweather is too fast and skilled to let Cotto make a fight out of it, that one would be a one sided snoozer.

I don't think we'll ever see a Calz-Pavlik fight.  Calz seems to me to be writing the last chapter on his career and seems more likely to fight a guy like Jones, that has perceived to have lost some oomph rather than a young bull in Pavlik, who would wear Calz out and send him into retirement with an ugly loss.

Cotto Mayweather will probably happen if Cotto can stay the course and keep winning to gain enough prestige to win Mayweather's attention.  Money May likes easy cash.

Answer 7

Mayweather & Cotto

Answer 8

Calzaghe/Pavlik because both fighters come to fight, both fighters let their hands go, both fighters do not mind trading punches. I think Pavlik would beat Calzaghe because he has a solid chin and great punching power and I believe Calzage would want something to prove and would be willing to trade with Pavlik.

Answer 9

I'd say Cotto-Mayweather. Both matchups are very interesting.  I really would like to see Cotto vs. Mayweather.  I think Calzaghe is too old for Pavlik.  Pavlik is amazing and the matchup between Cotto-Mayweather seems to be closer IMO atleast.

Answer 10

Cotto-Mayweather is much more likely, now that Calzaghe  is a lightheavy.  Not that Joe can't move back down, but why should Pavlik move up when he's THE middleweight champion?  He just won the belt, let him enjoy it a bit.  

Which would I rather see?  Calzaghe-Pavlik, of course.  But I'm really doubting that it'll ever happen.

Answer 11

They would be both great fights .  I especially like the fight of the Welterweights Cotto vs Mayweather a good decent productive fight between two talented Champions.

Answer 12

If mayweather is willing to fight toe to toe and punch for punch, than no matter what calzaghe/pavlik do, the cotto vs. mayweather will be better... if he just runs and use his hit and run concept, than it'll be another boring fight and calzaghe and pavlik will be better... To me, i want cotto to win and pavlik to win.....

But thinking truthfully, mayweather has a higher chance of winning and Calzaghe has a better chance of winning... Mayweather is just faster and very skilled while calzaghe has speed with power... i don't know if cotto or pavlik can handle... but if the fight does happen, I am rooting for cotto and pavlik all the way... which i want cotto to get a knockout and pavlik gets a TKO over calzaghe.....

Answer 13

cotto-mayweather