Question:

Which of the 3 shoudl carlton get?

by | earlier

0 LIKES Like UnLike

jeff white, johnathan brown or daniel kerr

Tags:

Report

Answer The Question I've Same Question Too

Follow Question

18 ANSWERS

Sort By: Date | Rating

So you're saying that Carlton can pick which one they like, and the player will come straight to the club?

Brown won't leave Brissy, and if he does, why would the Blues want him? They already have a power forward in Fev.

Jeff White would just be there to fill in the gap until Kreuzer develops more. I wouldn't waste my time on White.

Kerr probably doesn't even want to leave the Eagles. If he does, he will go to another club offering him a bigger salary, since Carlton surely have no room left in their salary cap! Oh wait, maybe they'll cheat again!

I think Carlton should develop some of their own players, and stop stealing them off other clubs :)

No offence intended Blues supporters!
Report (0) (0) | earlier
They will not get any and they should not get any but if i were to wish one of those player on carlton it would be jeff white he has gone from star to dud

Tjosh i think kerr is only 24 so i don't know why you think he is past his prime.

catriona58 i think you will find that he is out of contract this year and he wants to come to melbourne.so i don't no were you get you mail from
Report (0) (0) | earlier
kerr

i read a story today he wants to play for a real footy team
Report (0) (0) | earlier
I quote the West Australian Newspaper, page 70, Thursday August 21 2008, Paragraph 2 "Kerr is contracted to the Eagles for 2009.." So he is indeed a contracted player at WCE for 2009.

I would suspect Carlton won't have the money to pay for Brown which only leaves Jeff White. So I guess my answer is: Jeff White (Same Newspaper articla above mentions that Melbourne will be targeting and experienced ruckman.....
Report (0) (0) | earlier
Mate - stop right there.

You are concluding the fact that they are going to move to Carlton and thats it, i dont think think that Jonathan Brown will move (hes won three premierships with the lions - but there is that tiny chance he may move - just remind yourself what jason akermanis did) And im not entirelly sure about Jeff white, i think he might go to carlton but the chance he will is not as big as the other two players you have mentioned. Daniel Kerr has said on radio stations that he wants to stay an eagle and in the West Australian Newspaper today there was an article on Daniel Kerr and how his managers will be discussing with the eagles about his contract and stuff associated with him and where he will be (contracts etc.). Kerr stated that he wants to stay an eagle and is happy to play on for west coast.
Report (0) (0) | earlier
none. stop stealing players, and try developing your own.
Report (0) (0) | earlier
Answer with a question......... HUH?????
Report (0) (0) | earlier
We don't really need Kerr as our midfield is already pretty strong. White's past it. So the answer would have to be Jonathon Brown. Another focal point up forward would be nice. Actually it would be brilliant!

Can't see it happening though...

Edit. None taken lozz!
Report (0) (0) | earlier
Not brown, cos i go for brisbane.

Not kerr, he is past his prime.

Not white, he is gettin old.
Report (0) (0) | earlier
Carlton should save their money and sign up some more kids.
Report (0) (0) | earlier
none they are all too good

u dont need any your club is corrupt
Report (0) (0) | earlier
I think you'll find Daniel Kerr is signed on 'till 2009 and is discussing his new contract soon and Can I mention he wants to stay with the eagles.

And he hasn't actually confirmed he is moving but he has however confirmed he would love to stay at west coast.
Report (0) (0) | earlier
carlton alredi hav a great midfield n hav fev who is a great forward, i think they should try to get white coz they need a decent ruckman to knock the ball towards their awesome midfield!
Report (0) (0) | earlier
DON'T EVEN THINK ABOUT IT!!!!!

Would you like our whole team, while your at it!

Daniel kerr is contracted with the eagles until the end of 2009.

FYI - Stop taking teams captains!!!

EDIT:

think about this... eagles trade kerr for judd lol ....wouldn't that be funny! although you still can't have him!
Report (0) (0) | earlier
Yea stop taking top players from every team, its not like Carlton is buysing them, their just getting people like d**k HEAD PRATT to pay for the players not Carlton foorball club!!

I know, why dont you go and tank and you can get the #1 draft!!
Report (0) (0) | earlier
Ofence taken Lozz. =0

Well we could use all of them.

Jeff White - Until Kruze develops.

Browny - Forward to help Fev.

Daniel Kerr - boost the midfeild up allittle bit more.
Report (0) (0) | earlier
NOT BROWNY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

(i go 4 lions.. u better not take him!)

kerr is overrated

i dunno who jeff white is :/
Report (0) (0) | earlier
Experience with recycled players is that it takes them a while to develop into the new team, even Judd, and they don't commit fully for the long haul - Michael, Camporeale, Aker come to mind.

Any of the three above are really superfluous to Carlton's needs once their Tank Tops develop - next year should show that.

Mr Pratt needs to realise that money can't buy genius. Or even rent it.
Report (0) (0) | earlier