Which of these players will become the most successful during their career?

Question

Try to base your judgement on the players ability, the players role at his current club, and the players potential. Also try not to be biased in your answer please!

a) Theo Walcott (Arsenal)

b) Samir Nasri (Arsenal)

c) John Obi Mikel (Chelsea)

d) Salomon Kalou (Chelsea)

e) Ryan Babel (Liverpool)

f) Daniel Agger (Liverpool)

g) Anderson (Manchester United)

h) Nani (Manchester United)

Thanks :)

Answer 1

before i answer this question i would like to say that i am a spurs supporter so cannot be biased...   in my view theo walcott is the most talented of these players followed by nasri and and babel but this is a different question...

i think that united have an advantage over the other two but i wil stick with walcott and nani second

Answer 2

a) Theo Walcott (Arsenal)- athletico madrid

b) Samir Nasri (Arsenal) -arsenal

c) John Obi Mikel (Chelsea) -chelsea

d) Salomon Kalou (Chelsea) -juventus

e) Ryan Babel (Liverpool) -sevilla

f) Daniel Agger (Liverpool) -loivpool

g) Anderson (Manchester United) -ac milan

h) Nani (Manchester United -manutd

Answer 3

define successful, nani and anderson have already achieved what most players can only dream of.

nani and anderson have the potential to be world class players, out of the rest maybe nasri would be 3rd

Answer 4

Ryan Babel (Liverpool),Theo Walcott (Arsenal) and Samir Nasri (Arsenal)

Answer 5

I would have to say Theo Walcott, but all of the listed players should be very successful.  

Answer 6

That is a really tough Q as I know little of Nasri and we have seen only glimpses of what the other players can do! How you can compare Centre backs to attacking midfielders to wingers is beyond me!

Walcott, Mikel, Kalou, Babel: I odn't rate at all really

Nani, Agger: A lot to prove and have more in them. Doubt whether they will be that successful

Anderson: Has the ability to be a great player! Whether he will or not we can only wait and see! He bossed the midfield at Anfield last season against Masherano and Gerrard!! He is so strong and a great worker!

EDIT: How can we judge on career success when they have only arrived on the scene? Thats daft! At a guess cause thats all we can do I'd still say Anderson

But of course the only two to win something there are Nani and Anderson..does that mean they are the best! Champions League and Premiership medals!!

Answer 7

im a newcastle fan and i say NANI.

i think he has the potential to be following ronado. i think the rest will probably be good but not world beaters.

Answer 8

Nani. He will replace Ryan Giggs ina few seasons time and he will have more playing time.

Answer 9

you sound like a horrible little Kopite rat, block me instead of the other fellow, don't you like his answers, don't you like his honesty, i hate your smarminess you don't belong on here not him.

Babbel and agger are s****.

what about James Vaughan being on your list.

YNW again.

I also like to speak the truth.

Answer 10

Nani>>> I liked his performance in charity shield... and I think he is starting to prove his worth... his pace and skills are amazing.

I admire Theo Walcott...got a bright future...

Answer 11

As much as it kills me to say it I think Anderson will.

Answer 12

None.

Answer 13

Im a Liverpool fan!

i think probably Theo Walcott, coz hes young an nice looking an has a pretty gf that may go inot modeling. But i dont think any1 could be like David Beckham i think hes a 1 off!

Answer 14

Nani, give him 2 more years with SAF then u'll c what an amazing player he'll mould out to be, u have to admitfor his first season he did have some amazing games and not to mention his goals he scored :). But most of the people of that list will also make it big in the football game.

Answer 15

Theo Walcott (not being biased at all, total truth)

This coming season will show that he's not only a young player but hes a very quick player, very strong player, very agile, great team player and shall be scoring alot more goals and having alot more 1st team chances than he did last season (some due to his shoulder injury).

He will be World class within 3-5 years.

The only fault with Theo, which i hope he shall correct this season, he's got to be more selfish and take more goal chances himself instead of hesitating and passing to others to get the goal.

Answer 16

Walcott will play a v. crucial role at Arsenal this season (the other big 4 clubs have too many other options anyway for their midfield to need their youngsters)

Walcott has the most potential for greatness under the guidance of the brilliant mentor Arsene Wenger.

Just a little biased though ;)

Answer 17

I think Walcott will do well this season and will have him in my dream team! What about Modric?

Answer 18

Good question:

a) Theo Walcott (Arsenal)- Will grow up to be an England regular, but probably not a world class player. He'll be one of these players that will be recognisable to every football fan in Europe, but he will never be one of the best in the world, just a handfull for defenders.

b) Samir Nasri (Arsenal)- Will be a star for France. His tag as the new Zidane won't be justified, but he will be one of the best midfielders in the world when he matures.

c) John Obi Mikel (Chelsea)- Will forever underachieve because of his attitude. He'll never be recognised as a particularly special player, and will sink into obscurity.

d) Salomon Kalou (Chelsea)- Much like Walcott, he will be a handfull for years to come for defences, but it is unlikely he will ever achieve more than that.

e) Ryan Babel (Liverpool)- It really depends how he will mature. He seems to be a bit of a headless chicken at the moment. If he sorts his head out, he could be another that will trouble European defences for years to come. But he'll never be world class.

f) Daniel Agger (Liverpool)- He could one day be the best defender in the world. He's an agile centre-back who's already faultless when he plays. He will be one of the world's best centre backs in a few years. But defenders are rarely rewarded for their abilities.

g) Anderson (Manchester United)- Another who needs to mature in the right way. He's a different kind of midifelder. I can't see him carrying on a lot past his 30th birthday, but he will be 1st choice for Brazil in a few years, and will prove to be a very gifted midfielder.

h) Nani (Manchester United)- Everybody compares him with Ronaldo. If he stabalises like Ronaldo did, he'll be one of the top players in Europe. He's already got the touch, pace and acrobatics, now Fergie needs to drill some sense into him.

On the whole I think it will be Nani, just ahead of Agger.

Answer 19

I think Theo Walcott would be the most successful...because firstly he is british and he would be given more chances to show his talent than the other players above.

Answer 20

Well I'm an arsenal fan so I'm going to say wallcot and narsi both a key role in this years cup :D

Answer 21

I think Theo has an excellent chance of being successful his is just awesome but that really depends on what happens at Arsenal over the next few years and if Wenger actually starts using him as a striker because that is what he is!

Also i think Mikel has a great chance now Makelele has gone but i'm not sure how Scolari will use him.

Babel certainly has the talent but i was expecting much better things from him last season (there were certainly glimpses of his talent) he really needs to step his game up.

Anderson well as long as he improves on his goal scoring then i think he will be awesome, i honestly think we have found a viable replacement for Scholes which i never thought we could do!

Nani like Babel definitely has the ability but last season i just felt he was more bothered about trying to out do Ronaldo so hopefully Sir Alex  has given him a slap and he'll concentrate on him own game from now on.

The others i really don't have an opinion on.

If i had to choose one then I would have to go for Walcott, if anyone doubts his talent then just look at his run in the CL against Liverpool it was scary and he had the composure at the end of it to square the ball to a team mate most players would of had a shot after a run like that especially in such a big game, its just a shame they didn't manage to win because i think that would of been one of those moments where everyone around the world would have stood up and taken notice, like Beckham's halfway line lob, Owen's goal against the Argies and to some extent Rooney's goal against Arsenal (although he hasn't lived up to his hype). But like i said it all depends on Arsenal and Wenger.