Which of these <span title="injuries.........Malarchuk,">injuries.........Malarchu...</span> Zednik, Berard????

Question

Which of the following hockey injuries is the hardest for you to watch? Whether it be because it's the most graphic, or because you were actually at the game when it happened, or because they were on your favorite team.....give me your reason.

Bryan Berard...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CdyHVGPdwT4

Clint Malarchuk...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dR-wA4SmbO4

Richard Zednik...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vjoByuFt1_8

Lame question, I know. But I'm debating with myself which one is the hardest for me to watch..........and I thought I'd see what others say.

(BTW, Yahoo wanted to put this in 'Horse racing')

Answer 1

malarchuk

Answer 2

They were all bad. The Zednik one hits home because I am a Panthers fan. But the Malarchuk one was worse. He almost died on the ice

Answer 3

Malarchuk.... yet i think even Trent McCleary&#039;s injury was harder to watch than the Berard one...

Answer 4

Malarchuk simply because Bedard&#039;s injury would have been less significant (and / or possibly avoided) with the use of a visor.

Answer 5

Malardchuk.

Answer 6

Malarchuk. All of them are pretty gruesome but honestly when Clint started bleeding (I actually remember the scene when it happened) I think pretty much everybody expected him to die. Eye injuries are nasty but blindness was the concern at the moment these ocurred, when Clints neck started pumping blood death seemed to be on everyones mind. You hate to see any nasty injuries (the cheap shot by Turtle Lemieux to Draper was pretty gruesome too) but to fear for any players life just goes beyond nasty.  

Answer 7

Malarchuk&#039;s the scariest because it looked like he had gills. But, I think Berard&#039;s the scariest non-life threatening because it&#039;s his eye and that&#039;s anybody&#039;s livelihood right there. You got your whole future to re-plan and things like that. As grizzly as Zednik&#039;s injury was, it wasn&#039;t as gruesome as Malarchuk&#039;s, because he acted quickly enough on his own which said to me that the blood loss wasn&#039;t as severe as the goalie&#039;s.

Answer 8

I hadn&#039;t seen the Berard one until just now but back when Zednick got injured, I youtubed both his and Malarchuk&#039;s injuries and Malarchuk&#039;s almost made me pass out.  All 50 times I re-watched it. lol  

Answer 9

Clint Marlarchuk when is Neck got sliced

Answer 10

These kinds of things aren&#039;t painful for me to watch, but Berard&#039;s seemed the hardest to watch out of all of them.

This was another painful one too.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2dJOxIBe5...

Answer 11

Clint Malarchuk

Answer 12

Malarchuk&#039;s. That should never happen on the ice. Poor guy.

Sammy: I&#039;m going to report you every single time you answer a question in this section until you leave. Remember what your mommy said: &quot;If you don&#039;t have something nice to say, don&#039;t say anything at all.&quot;