Which of these statements is false?

Question

These three things cannot coexist:

1) Evil exists

2) God is omnibenevolent

3) God is omnipotent

One of these three statements is false. Which one is it?

Answer 1

They are all correct.  I believe you wanted us to answer with 2, but God sends rain on the wicked and the righteous.

Answer 2

Evil must exist for God to be omnibenevolent.  Otherwise, you're just a robot.

Answer 3

Why does the existence of God make it impossible for evil to exist?

We are humans and as such, some of us are evil.

Answer 4

Number 2

Answer 5

2 and 3.

Answer 6

All of the above are false.

Answer 7

2

Answer 8

2 Should be "God is a Just God."

Answer 9

Nbr 2

Answer 10

2 and 3 are false

Answer 11

*drink*

I agree. A Creator-of-All cannot be omnibenevolent.

ADD: Is there any objective way to tell the difference between really believing a deity is benevolent and the apotropaic fear of angering a vengeful deity?

Apotrope (adj.: apotropaic) refers to objects such as amulets, talismans, incantations, or other symbols and phrases intended to "ward off evil" or "avert or combat evil.”

If I call my boss “the best boss in the world” do I really mean that he is the best boss in the world or that I WANT him to be a nice boss to me, so I am kissing up to him.

If I call a large, growling, drooling, guard dog that stands between me and the exit “nice doggie” do I really mean that it is a nice dog or am I trying to convince it (and me) that I am not a threat and should be allowed to move on peacefully?

If I tell my Significant Other “You are the only woman in the world” do I really mean that all the other women have died due to some strange misogynistic disease, or am I telling her romantic white lies that I am only attracted to her?

Answer 12

If we assume the truth of the myth, they are all true, to someone.

If, OTOH, we do not, accept the myth, then they are all false

Answer 13

All are false.

Answer 14

They're all false.

Answer 15

Yup, 2 & 3.

Answer 16

        God,in whatever form one believes,gets the 'rap' 4 way to much!!!

NONE of these statements are false... #1.Evil exists yeah,but only

because God, in His omnipotent benevolence, gave Man 'free will'.

So evil is the shortcoming of MAN & NOT God. It sounds like u r

looking 4 an analytical excuse to not believe n a god...

                                                                                GOD

Answer 17

All of them are false.  Evil is a subjective concept and there are no gods.

Answer 18

Assuming God exists, 2.

Answer 19

Answering within the confines of a logic puzzle I believe the false statement is number 2.  God is omnibenevolent.  Evil could not exist if there was an omnibenevolent God.

Answer 20

you are wrong they can coexist

God is eternally good

God has unlimited power

Evil does exist because it is the opposite of choosing to disobey God

Answer 21

Since "God" doesn't exist, both 2 & 3 are false.

.