Which of these trades would you rather take?

Question

In fantasy baseball, which of these trades would you rather do, if I was definitely going to do one?

Give up Hanley Ramirez and Rick Ankiel for David Wright and Furcal.

or Give up Hanley Ramirez, Griffey, and Zack Grienke for David Wright and Furcal.

I'm definitely doing one because I need a 3rd baseman.

Answer 1

id rather take it up the butt

Answer 2

give up ankiel he is a power bat but k's way too much and does not play everyday...

Answer 3

Both are good trades for you, but I'd do the first one.

Hanley has been struggling a bit lately, but he's still worthy of a top 5 player. However, Wright is arguably better. Both players don't hurt you in any category. Ankiel is solid, but he can be very inconsistent and strikes out a lot. Furcal surely won't continue to put up his pre-DL numbers, but he's still better than Ankiel. I would choose the 2nd trade over the 1st trade because I wouldn't want to give up Greinke. Greinke is a good young pitcher. Then again, it depends on who you could add. Still, take the first trade.

Hope I helped!