Which of these two necklaces makes the better gift?

Question

I'm trying to pick out a gift for my bridesmaids. Their dresses are hot pink. So I originally chose the first necklace. However, after thinking about it. I thought that the gift is a little self centered. Just because I like pink doesn't mean they want a pink necklace! So then I found necklace number 2. Do you think necklace number 2 is the better gift? or is it boring?? Any other suggestions?

Answer 1

I like the one with less pink. Great choice however- circle, rings, and circle of life.

Answer 2

Both are gorgeous.

I say buy the pink one. It will look gorgeous on the day of the wedding.

They'll still be able to wear it on other occasions and if it has the wedding color it's more significant.

Good Luck and Congratulations.

Answer 3

Personally, I would buy them the regular diamond one as opposed to the pink sapphire one. They can wear it with other outfits besides just the bridesmaid dress.

The last time I got jewelry matching my bridesmaid dress...well, I haven't worn it again.

Answer 4

I think either would be nice.  Or give heach girl a necklace in her own birthstone

Answer 5

Option 1.

Answer 6

The simple clear one is beautiful. It can be worn with other things. However the pink one is unique and is a memento of the wedding.

Answer 7

I like the idea of the more simple one, only because they would be able to wear it with more things after the wedding.  The one without the pink can be worn with anything, the one with pink can be worn with pink, white, or black.  But you are the one that's buying them, so what do you want them to be wearing on your wedding day?

Answer 8

I like #1.Very elegant

Answer 9

I think they're both lovely but I think the simple one would be more appropriate as they could wear it with anything.  

Answer 10

Love the pink

go with gut instinct!!

1st choice is one you

should use!

Good Luck

Answer 11

They are both beautiful, but if it were me, I would choose the non-pink :)

If their flowers are also pink, along with their dresses, then it would be an over-load of pink. The white diamond would be a nice classic break and look very elegant. Your bridesmaids would also be able to wear it with anything in their wardrobe, and not be limited to what matches pink.

What a beautiful and generous gift. I'm sure your girls will love whichever you choose, as it is a gift from your heart!!!

Congrats and good luck on your special day!!!

♥ & *muahs*

Answer 12

I think it's better to go with the neutral.

However, that style of necklace is usually the type given by a boyfriend or husband...

I gave my bridesmaids lockets -

http://www.amazon.com/Sterling-Silver-He...

http://www.amazon.com/Sterling-Silver-En...

Some ideas -

http://www.gordonsjewelers.com/product/i...

http://www.gordonsjewelers.com/product/i...

http://www.palmbeachjewelry.com/jump.jsp...

http://www.amazon.com/Sterling-Diamond-N...

http://www.amazon.com/Sterling-Zirconia-...

http://www.amazon.com/Sterling-Zirconia-...

Answer 13

I like the pink necklace

Answer 14

I like the basic one (not the pink). Unless the pink mmatches exactly, it would look off. Plus, with having bright pink dresses anyways, that may be way too much pink. The other (non pink) one they can also use with many different outfits, so that would be the most versitile.

Answer 15

I think you're right that the white diamond necklace might be more of a crowd-pleaser. And trust me, it's not boring. It's gorgeous, classic, and elegant. Your maids will able to wear them for years to come.

Answer 16

I personally like pink, but I would go with the clear.  It's more wearable.  And you don't want to overload them with pink everything.

Answer 17

I think both of them are really nice and would make lovely gifts.

If there is more than one you could buy one of each.

Either you pick or they pick which one they would prefer.

Both lovely though.

Very ncie present.

Answer 18

don't get the pink one.  they'll be able to wear the clear one more often than the pink.

Answer 19

They are both really nice!  I do feel number 2 is better, b/c not everyone likes pink and then they can wear it with anything not just stuff with pink.

Answer 20

I like the simple one.  If the girls dresses are pink then you want something to set the color off not blend with the dress.

Good Luck!!

Answer 21

I think the diamond necklace is better.

a) just in case they don't like pink

b) higher chance they will use it again, it's more adaptable