Which of these two similar drawings is better?

Question

1. http://img107.imageshack.us/img107/2569/img0097ry2.jpg

2. http://img526.imageshack.us/img526/1660/img0099ys3.jpg

Personally, I think the girls are better in the second one and the boys are better in the first but I can change how the boys look in the second one a little...I think I'll do that but what's your opinion?

I can make little line edits if you like one version better but think something little would look better changed.

I know they are very similar but whatever pick one. Both are screwed up in different ways and I haven't gotten to fix them yet but which overall is better?

Answer 1

first. really nice drawings btw

Answer 2

change boys in second one.  second one is best

Answer 3

the first but it looks like she has a black coochy

Answer 4

the 2nd one has more detail but they both seem good

Answer 5

they look like the same thing  

Answer 6

1st one:

Too many lines.

Eyes too small and not stylized.

Girl on the left is missing the hawt knee-highs.

Characters have no expression.

2nd one:

Clean but still a bit rough.

What's that black spot on the girls hair?

Why the extra lines on the girl on the left?

Somebody forgot to erase a line on the leg of the girl on the right.

Guy on the right's hand is part of the girl on the right.

Overall the second one looks better after a few fixes.

Answer 7

i think the first one is better. i looks more like a work of art....

Answer 8

honestly as an artist myself i cant say i like your work but its good so i give u chops i like both cause there both good i think i like the second cause the shading gives them a little more depth and contrast.

Answer 9

Second.

The first one, the boy on the right, his head is just a tad weird. n.n''

Answer 10

second 1

Answer 11

that'd be #2

Answer 12

I like the second one more...

If these are your drawings you are GREAT!

Answer 13

The second one :)

For sure!!

Answer 14

i don't like either one of them one bit! (sorry!) you wanted me to be honest so i am. but if i had to choose one that i liked more i would choose the second one (even though they both are the exact same thing) because in the first picture, the faces are to weird and in the second, it's a little better. also, i think your drawings look to kid-ish. i do like anime and manga and i actually draw it.

P.S. anime are the shows and manga are the books/drawings. you can like anime but not manga.

Answer 15

They are both good!

Answer 16

The 1st one because the boys are the better of the two pictures.  The girls need work in the area of the eyes and mouth but there is a lot of potential there.

Answer 17

2

Answer 18

I like the first merely becasue there appears to be more detail.

Answer 19

Not a fan of anime art, but I think the first one is better.

Answer 20

To me I think the second one is better. But both of them are really good! You are a very good drawer!

Answer 21

I think the second is a little better, but like you said needs some editing.

Answer 22

The second one.  Because on the first one it was way to dark on the upper part of the one girls legs.

Answer 23

I like the second one for sure.

Answer 24

I like the second one better, its cuter and more flirty!

Answer 25

the second one is a little better

I really don't understand the fascination with anime.

really, really

Answer 26

idk one the girls look better

two boys look better

sorry cant decided

lovely drawings  

Answer 27

i think uve got talent, but i liked the first one better except i couldnt tell if the girls had eyelids or that little watery eyes thing that happens alot in anime. but id say first one