Which of these two trades in fantasy football should i do?

Question

should i trade larry johnson away for santonio holmes (or dwayne bowe) and maurice jones drew

if i do this trade who should i get dwayne bowe or santonio holmes?

or should i trade marvin harrison and larry johnson for santonio holmes dwayne bowe maurice jones drew and kevin boss (the new tight end for the giants)

will i be getting ripped off in any of these trades and why??

my team is:

tom brady

marvin harrison

roddy white

santana moss

willie parker

ryan grant

antonio gates

owen daniels

nate burleson

donte stallworth

larry johnson

matt hasselback

and jonathan stewart

Answer 1

You cannot do these trades.  Without Larry Johnson you have two RBs that should not be relied on as weekly starters in FFL.  Willie Parker is feast or famine every week and is now a number 3 or 4 RB (with Mendenhall, I would say 4).  Ryan Grant has had one great season but look at history as an indicator of fantasy RBs you will see a lot of "1 hit wonders" and even more so if you look at those who were drafted late in the NFL draft.

Answer 2

Dont do either trade. Larry could be a huge scorrer this year. Dont trade him away

Answer 3

For Sure!  Do either trade but I would pick the first one.

Jones-Drew is as good as LJ and is on a better team + you get a WR thrown in!  I would pick S.Holmes.

Answer 4

why do you want to get rid of a guy that could be your best point scorer at running back and a guy that could be your best point scorer at reciever?  Both of those trades sound bad. Of the big-time fantasy players you have (Brady, Harrison, Parker, Gates, Johnson, Hasselbeck), the only ones I might entertain trading would be Hasselbeck and if the price is right Gates.

Answer 5

I would do the first trade, because u want to keep harrison even tho he is injury prone, and u dont need a TE, so i would do the first trade and get holmes because they r both projected to hav good years, but pitts passing game is better with big ben rather than brodie croyle.