Question:

Which one of these active players is more likely to go to the HOF?

by  |  earlier

0 LIKES UnLike

Jim Edmonds

Vlad Guerrero

Carlos Lee

Kevin Millar(cowboy up)

Ichiro

 Tags:

   Report
Answer The Question I've Same Question Too

11 ANSWERS

Sort By: Date  |  Rating

  1. Vlad Guerrero. If Ichiro plays long enough he will make it too.


  2. Ichiro because the guys voting for the HOF will vote for him since he is foreign. Don't get me wrong he is an amazing hitter and will likely have 3 more 200+ hit seasons.

  3. Vlad Guerrero hands down.  Hes like 32 and he have 385 career homers, batting .322 in his career and 170 SB to boot.  

    EDIT: And did you just add Ichiro?  Anyways Ichiro will head to the HOF too.

  4. In order:

    Guerrero

    Ichiro

    Lee

    Edmonds

    Millar

    Guerrero will have the lifetime statistics to get in on the first ballot. Ichiro may go down with a more impressive career, but some voters may be ignorant of the fact that he won't be able to play as long. He's in a Koufax situation: will dominate the game, but won't have to time to rack up the numbers. He's deserving of Cooperstown though.

    These are in the order of how likely they are to get in, not who I think deserves to get in the most.

  5. Ichiro is a lock if he plays 10 seasons (minimum to qualify for HOF). And Vlad Guerrero is also a lock as long as don't find out he's taking Steroids.

  6. In order:

    Guerrero

    Ichiro

    Lee

    Edmonds

    Millar (who really has no shot other than the emotional pleas from Red Sox fans.)  

  7. Vlad should get there, same with Ichiro.  The others will have to buy tickets like everyone else.

  8. Are you serious with Millar??  If Edmonds was completely healthy in his career, I think his numbers would be close to HOF worthy but he has no chance.  Vlad and Ichiro are locks.  Carlos Lee is a 1 trick pony that can hit with the best of them(esp against the Cubs)but I don't see him as HOF worthy.  He would need over 2500 hits, 400+ Hr's 1800 RBI's to have a chance.  

  9. Guerrero and Ichiro

  10. jim edmonds...best defensive CF of all time, along with 360+ HRs

  11. Vlad Guerrero.  He is the best all-around player on the list. Ichiro is good but Vlad is more of a star.
You're reading: Which one of these active players is more likely to go to the HOF?

Question Stats

Latest activity: earlier.
This question has 11 answers.

BECOME A GUIDE

Share your knowledge and help people by answering questions.
Register Now