Which option is better---buying a used piano or buying a digital piano/workstation?

Question

I have always wanted to learn how to play the piano, and my husband is purchasing one this year for my birthday. Tonight, we are on our way to view a slightly used piano that's been in the seller's family for ages. However, I've heard that the Casio Privia PX-800, Yamaha YPG-625 and the Casio PX 800 on YouTube/ Manufacturer's Site , and they sound just as awesome. What is the best option for me to choose? Please help me since I'm just trying to find the best item to start with since I'm a novice.

Answer 1

Real pianos have a different sound than a keyboard and many piano players swear by them.  Pianos are VERY heavy.  You may need to hire someone to move it.

Keyboards play many different  sounds and are light and portable.

As a novice,  I would start with the keyboard.  It will be easier to sell if you decide that you are not going to pursue the instrument.

Answer 2

Go with the digital.  You will have more options: portability, MIDI compatible (for when you get good and want to record), never having to pay someone to tune the thing. I had a Roland  EP-8 and loved it.  The keys are weighted and touch responsive, just like a real piano.  And then there is the price.  If you sink a bunch of money into a solid-wood piano and then lose interest, you may have a hard time re-selling it.  And you will also have to move the thing when you move.

Answer 3

I would defiantly go digital. They are easy to move, you can use headphones if you want to play late at night.

I prefer the Casio privia because it has a wooden stand with a three pedal unit built in. This is useful because you have a fixed damper (sustain) pedal.

The problem with the Yamaha is that you have to plug a sustain pedal in the back of the piano and after playing for a while the pedal moves out of reach. I have played one myself and it’s a real pain.