Which phone would you recommend from ATT?

Question

Which free phone would you recommend for a seventh grader? This would be my first phone that i dont have to share with my brother. i want phone that looks cute, have good camera and video, and is easy to use.

Also, what do you think of these phones?

Nokia 6085 - Pink

http://www.wireless.att.com/cell-phone-service/cell-phone-details/?device=Nokia+6085+-+Pink&q_sku=sku1180006

Sony Ericsson Z310a - Lush Pink

http://www.wireless.att.com/cell-phone-service/cell-phone-details/?device=Sony+Ericsson+Z310a+-+Lush+Pink&q_sku=sku1020100

Sony Ericsson W580i Walkman® - Pink

http://www.wireless.att.com/cell-phone-service/cell-phone-details/?device=Sony+Ericsson+W580i+Walkman%C2%AE+-+Pink&q_sku=sku1160040

Answer 1

get the third one

my friend has it and its cool

and flip phones are rly anoyin

Answer 2

nokia's are the most durable, but if you want a music phone get the sony ericsson w580 i, because it's music compatable.

also form factor is a big deal, do you like flip phones, or sliders?

as i have had a phone since 4th grade i have found that nokia's are the most reliable, and durable so if you are hard on phones get the nokia.

Answer 3

BlackBerry Pearls are all the rage for younger females.  

Answer 4

I would say forget about the Sony Ericsson Z310a. It has the lowest rating, people say it feels cheap and that the call quality is kind of bad. The Walkman has better picture quality, but I've heard that the battery life is kind of bad. I would get the Walkman, since I think it's really cute, but both are good phones.

Answer 5

the 3rd one is the best!

Answer 6

the second one.

Answer 7

i think the sony ericsson w580i is good

Answer 8

I work at att and i deal with returns the z310 is a constant returned phone.  The 6085 is good all around but it takes terrible pictures the w580i is an excellent choice but get insurance on it because the keys crack on it sometimes and if its after a year they wont cover it on the warranty.  hope this helps.  If you can spend a little bit on a phone i would go with the lg shine its an awesome phone all around and you should be able to get it for around 50 bucks after a mail in rebatre

Answer 9

Here are the CNET reviews for your given list of phones, in the order that you gave them:

http://reviews.cnet.com/cell-phones/noki...

http://reviews.cnet.com/cell-phones/sony...

http://reviews.cnet.com/cell-phones/sony...  (White was the only one that had a review).

I like the third on the list personally.  

The Samsung BlackJack2 in Blue is really cool too.

http://reviews.cnet.com/smartphones/sams...

If money isn't an issue, then get the iPhone! :) But it doesn't have video, or MMS...

I'd go with the third on your list personally overall.

Answer 10

well personally i think the last one is the cutest.  but i just got the samsung slider from att for free. its refurbished but looks and acts brand new.  its amazing.  i LOVE it.  Amazing camera and video.  and all my friends LOVEEEE playing with it.  its great for texting.  and it's a little more sophisticated looking but cute.  Get it in orange or something.  you'll outgrow the pink i PROMISE.  i'm gonna be a sophomore in high school.  and pink is like ehh i got it i blue but whatever you decide. its your phone.  look at the reviews though that will help.  and the rating it got.  (how many stars)

good luck ;)