Which player is most worthy of being a top 10 pick this year?

Question

Jamal Lewis, Marshawn Lynch, Selvin Young, or Steve Smith?

Top 10, imo:

LT, AP,SJ, J addai. westbrook, brady, moss, gore, LJ, and????

Anyone else I missed? Portis? Barber?

Thanks.

Answer 1

M. Lynch 1st

J. Lewis 2nd

S. Smith 3rd

S. Young - N/A : Don't waste your time trying to figure out Shanny's BS RB committees!

Answer 2

None of those 4-6(?) choices. Either Peyton or Brady. Doesnt have to be running back.

Answer 3

Starred for your name...hilarious :)

I agree with that list (almost the same as yahoo's and espn's just mixed up a bit), but I really question Randy Moss being on it. Last year, defenses figured out how to stop him. I really worry he won't find his stride like last year.

I'm torn. I don't know if I'd put barber over Peyton but I think those to guys are either picks 9 and 10, 10 and 11 or 9 and 11.

I'd say Barber is prob. 9 and peyton 10.

Answer 4

Selvin Young? Are you kidding me? The way Shanahan plays musical running backs in Denver Torain may be the starter by the opening game.

Smith is good (assuming it's Smith from CAR and not from nYG) but Delhomme is coming back from an injury and if he can't go it will affect Smith's numbers.

Lewis was solid last year but he's old and may not hold up to another year of pounding.

That leaves Lynch as the best choice out of the 4 you've mentioned. He's the primary ball carrier in BUF and will get plenty of touches.

Still, I'd go with Portis at 10. He is the focal point of the offense in WAS.

Answer 5

Lynch or lewis

Answer 6

Peyton Manning, Reggie Wayne, Romo, Matt Hasselbeck, and Ryan Grant

Answer 7

Marion Barber or Clinton Portis most likely.