Which player would you rather have....?

Question

Jeff Carter or Milan Michalek??

Answer 1

michalek.  

Answer 2

Jeff Carter , great all around player , not whiny , scores goals , not too many penalties but not a complete un-physical player

:)  

Answer 3

Kyle Turris

Answer 4

Milan Michalek

Someone that can dangle, shoot, and also be aggresive.

Answer 5

jeff carter is a better all-around player and he is still young sooo .. i pick him

Answer 6

Jeff Carter-- Islanders need a decent center who isn't 37 years old.

Answer 7

Jeff Carter...very underrated, notched 30 goals this season and was unreal at the end of the year.

Answer 8

Of those two I would say Carter. He has shown me much more as a player so far .

Answer 9

Jeff Carter. He's the better all-around player.

Answer 10

Jeff Carter- more complete player