Which ring is better?

Question

My fiance and I have narrowed the choices on his ring. But neither of us can decide. He left the decision up to me but i like them both. Help me choose which one I should get him.

http://i28.photobucket.com/albums/c225/ringmastajuglo/ring1.jpg

http://i28.photobucket.com/albums/c225/ringmastajuglo/ring2.jpg

Answer 1

I really like the second one. Its very simple, but it looks really good.

congratulations!

Answer 2

I prefer the second one. Simple and shiney!!

Have a lovely wedding! x

Answer 3

Congrats to you both.. I personally like the second one better. As someone mentioned here you guys will like it for a long time and it's classy.

Answer 4

Sorry I dont like either, they both look unfinished with the lines only on one side.

If I were to pick though I would say second one and wear the line next to my engagement ring.

I prefer either patterned or plain not something in between but its all about personal choice.

Be happy which ever you choose.

Answer 5

2nd one

However, I prefer rings that aren't as shiny because they don't show scratches as much. If I had a ring that shiny, I'd have it all scratched up in a year or so. But, get what he wants. He's the one who has to wear it. Best wishes~

Answer 6

Personally I like the second one because it has a little more class.  I just think you may like it longer.  Then again, after this post you may say, "but I like the other one", then that is the one you choose.

Congrats on the proposal! Have a great wedding

Answer 7

The first one. It's shinier and I think it's cuter. =D

Answer 8

the second one. scratches will show up very obviously on the second one, not so much on the first.

Answer 9

the second one its more simple  

Answer 10

I think they are both lovely rings. Are they made of the same metal (platinum or white gold - how many carats)? The second ring is more 'in fashion' at the moment for grooms so may be more likely to go out I suppose. That said, they are both classy, simple designs. Do they both go well with your ring? Either ring is gorgeous so I don't think you can make a wrong decision. Good luck.

I just came back to this site. If the ring is titanium it shouldn't scratch easily  (it is more dent, bend and scratch resistant that gold or platinum). So it shouldn't matter much if its shiny. My wedding ring won't 'match' with my fiances but as long as it doesn't clash I don't think it matters in the slightest.

I would go with whichever ring you think you would like to see on his hand in 30 years. What would look good on an older person. Both rings are lovely but maybe that can be your deciding question.

Answer 11

The second one. He'd get tired of the stripe on the first.

Answer 12

First one, no doubt about it.

Answer 13

the first one is better

Answer 14

His ring should be HIS choice.

Answer 15

I agree. The second is better.

Answer 16

I prefer the second one. They are both nice but I like the plain one as it will age really well.

Answer 17

Congratulations on you upcoming wedding!

I like the second ring the most.

Answer 18

I like the 1st one...it's a little bit different than just the plain shiny one :)

Good luck and best wishes for your special day!!!

♥ & *muahs*

Answer 19

Second one