Which side is better for these trades?

Question

TRADE 1

Side A- brandon lyon, ryan howard, jacoby ellsbury

Side B- carlos beltran, aubrey huff, jay bruce, tim hudson

TRADE 2

Side A- brandon lyon and jacoby ellsbury

Side B- aubrey huff, jay bruce and tim hudson

Answer 1

for trade 1 side a because of ryan howard for trade 2 b because brandon lyon and jacoby ellsbury don't match aubrey huff jay bruce and tim hudson talent wise

Answer 2

trade 1 side b  and trade 2 would be side a