Which team benefits more by this fantasy football trade?

Question

team A gets: Carson Palmer, Plaxico Burress

team B gets: David Garrard, Marques Colston, Tedd Ginn Jr.

which team is getting the better end of the deal A or B?

Answer 1

Not even close...team A gets the best of this deal. Bottom line in fantasy is production and we know the Bengals will rely on their explosive passing game (big questions about their running game) and while Garrard has tools and manages a game well that is exactly what he does....manage games. This means he hands off the ball and and dinks and dunks most of the time (not fantasy friendly). Palmer easily out performs him fantasywise. Love Colston and think he might be the better receiver between him and Burress but the difference fantasywise will be marginal, not enough to offset the huge advantage with Palmer. Ginn still has to prove himself and with the QB spot unsettled  whoever gets Ginn gets a guy with potential but nothing more than that. And he has to cut someone....is this another guy with potential that he cuts? I would feel pretty good about being team A.

Answer 2

Team A. When Burress plays, he does really good. Palmer has good WR's to throw the ball to. He has Johnson and Houshmandzadeh which can get a lot of yards and TD's.

Team B is the down side. The only good player is Colston out of that deal. Ginn Jr. won't get that many yards this year. I don't think Garrard won't do good this year. That's what I think.  

Answer 3

A

Answer 4

TRavis b is a idot

ted ginn sucks

david garrard sucks

team a

Answer 5

team  a

Answer 6

Team B for sure

Answer 7

Yeah, easily team A.  Garrard could have a breakout season, but the only highlight of Team B there is Marques Colston, and he still hasn't fully proven himself.

Answer 8

Travis?  What are you smoking?

Team A for sure!  Team A aquires two proven players, who put up big numbers last season.  Although, the Bengals look very shaky this year, they still have both superstar WR's in T.J. and Ocho. (Although Ocho is more of an annoyance at the moment for the team.)  Palmer should still put up #1 QB numbers.  

And Plaxico is on a Giants team with a lot of confidence heading into the 08-09 season, as well as Eli Manning who loves to throw to Plax.