Which team wud win? { baseball }

Question

team a-

c- ivan rodriguez

1b- jason giambi

2b- alfonso soriano { he used to play 2b }

3b- alex rodriguez

ss- derek jeter

of- bobby abreu

of- hideki matsui

of- xavier nady

dh- miguel cabrera

pitching- Andy Pettite

or team b-

c- jason varitek

1b- carlos delgado

2b- freddy sanchez

3b- aramaris ramirez

ss- nomar garciaparra

of- JD drew

of- manny ramirez

of- johnny damon

dh- david ortiz

pitching- pedro martinez

Answer 1

Well I do see a pattern here.  Team A is past and present Yankee players (with the exception of Miguel Cabrera).  Team B is a team of past and present Red Sox players (exceptions being Sanchez, Ramirez and Delgado).  I'm trying to figure out why you picked these few stragglers that never played for either team.

To answer your question though, team A looks better on paper.

Answer 2

I would say Team A.  I like 2B, 3B,C, a lot better

Answer 3

Team A

Answer 4

team A has a better C, 2B, 3B, 1 better OF, better pitcher  

Answer 5

Does anybody really care?