Which xbox 360 live headset works better?

Question

the two im looking at are both wired. one has the mute/volume thing in the middle of the wire. the other has it attached to the controller. the older version worked really well for me, but it got stepped on.

Answer 1

Honestly these two used together are the best combination ever. The under ear headset is so comfortable and it works great, and the adapter makes it have volume controls at the base.

http://www.amazon.com/Xbox-360-Under-Ear...

http://www.amazon.com/Intec-DUS0166-I-Xb...

Answer 2

In my opinion, the one with the mute/volume at the jack would be better because its always there, instead of swinging around. As for working better, I think they would both be the same. Get the one by Microsoft, no 3rd party ones.