White Sox fans, would you rather see Griffey or Swisher in the everyday lineup?

Question

White Sox fans, would you rather see Griffey or Swisher in the everyday lineup?

Answer 1

I'd rather see Swisher because of the energy, use Griffey in situational at bats, or off the bench. His experience, and power will be great late in the game...

Answer 2

Griffey.  And I hope has restores credibility to the HR title.

Answer 3

Depends on what position.  Wait, actually it doesn't since you're going to get better defense with Swisher.  Their numbers are comparable but Griffey can't play in the field anymore.  With Griffey and Thome, you've really just got platooning DH players.

Answer 4

Swish. I just see Griffey as a declining player. With Swisher, he is still young, and can run. Griffey isn't the fastest guy out there, and that hurts in crunch time. Plus, Swish is a dedicated player taht will give it his all at all times.

Answer 5

Honestly, Griffey's defense in lacking in center and his offense isn't much better... Swisher has more power and is a safer bet defensively.

Answer 6

Griffey  

Answer 7

Swisher. Griffey is just about done.